The Archive · 1925

Magnitude of Police Work

Counsel then dwelt on the mag-nitride of police work in Shanghai. They had taken much trouble to in-farm themselves of the situation in and around Shanghai prior to the disturbances, and in this connexion the evidence of Chief Ins-poeter Givens must have impressed the Commissioners. The police administration here, he added, was quite out of the ordinary com] with possibly easy-going methods adopted at some places at home.

He was quite confident, concluded Mr. Newman, to leave" with the Commissioners for review the conduct of Capt. Martin on the day. in question. As he had said himself in the witness box, there was nothing he could have done which, in his opinion, he did not do.or which, if done afterwards, would have had any effect on the situation. Counsel's chief reason for urging this was because he thought that no man in Capt. Martin's position could -have anticipated—such, disorder when the students themselves never anticipated it. sector in summing up on the Ins pector's behalf he had in the first place to agree with Messrs. Macleod and Newman when they emphasized that there were a number of defendants. It was quite proper that there was no prosecution, and he would like to point out that it was possible to have a first-class defence with no prosecution. This perhaps applied more to his client than to anybody. If any man caused the Toss of human life the onus was placed upon him to justify his actions, and he could only do that 5 9 defence. But the fact that there was no prosecution made it difficult. Counsel would have to endeavour to formulate some reasonable principle of law under which man was justified in opening fire upon a mob. It wag an International Commission, and he did not think he could set forth Commission. He would set forth asa reasonable principle, however, that the taking of human life' was Justified if it was necessary in order to disperse a mob which if not] hed dispersed would be dangerous to life or property. This definition wae taken, in effect, from the papers concerning the Featherstone Riots.

was, he considered, a reasonable principle to work upon.

He would have to show, therefore, continued Mr. Reader-Harris, that it was necessary on this occasion to disperse a mob which if it was not dispersed would have been dangerous to life and property Before, however, desiing with the general facts of the case, he would Fefer to the Mobilization Instruetions, which were the Inspector's Bible on this occasion, and dwelt upon the powers held by anyone in charge to deal with emergencies before mobilisation actually oceur-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account