The Archive · 1920

BOOK REVIEWS

Tae New Map or Asta, by Herbert Adams Gibbons. New York, The New Century Ca.

Messrs. Kelly & Walsh have ent us this work by Dr. Gibbons, the author of the lew Map of Europe" and a similar Africa, The flamed parts of it suggest to the reader that they might have been taken wholesale from the "Jikh Shik Pao" of Tsinan, so remarkable is the resem-blanco, while the moderate sections are of the same_ style as the Jucubrations in the London "Daily News." Dz. Gibbons regards the British in the same light as does the Japanese editor of the T'sinanfu journal, and "the writings of the two ought to command about auch respect. At the same time while Great Britain is the bee noir of Dr. Gibbons, he uses the book to bring an_ indictment against most of the European powers, who with engaging frankness he describes as "consciencele: "hogs." With the aid of such language he arrives at the conclusion that European "eminent domain" in Asia must go, else the world is in for a war in comparison with which the recent struggle was a Saturday night brawl.

The bloodthirsty attacks upon Great Britain, who seems always to have been ready to plunge the world into strife the moment anybody mentioned India, are interesting to start with, but very quickly that interest. vanishes when the value of his information becomes more apparent. Hardly is the story of British wickedness well under way before we are faced with a statement such as the fol lowing:—'In the British Empire there are four forms of attachment to Great Britaii self-governing dominions, colonies, protectorates and dependencies. Sometimes, and this is the case in several instances in Asia, a British dependency is a country over which administrative contro] has not been extended or which has not been formally recognized as protectorate. Tt is simply within the British sphere of influence. Other powers must Keep out."

In the following page he gives as dependencies. among others, the Yangtze Valley. It is a pity that he did not amplify this part of his thesis, as probably no one would be more interested to hear about it than the inhabitants of the Yanetze Valley themselves. When an author, can seriously put forward statements of this sort. it leads fo a Brave suspicion that the rest of his arguments rest. on an equally peculiar basis, and may, therefore, ignored.

Dr. Gibbons states that he spent five years in the Ottoman Empire, and it looks very much as if that time was the only period during which he had any intimate ae quaintance with the East But after all to write a book on the Est one dors not require to hare resided there. Make a rechaufié of the literature of the agitators and extremists who are to be found

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account