It is reliably reported that the Chinese Government has replied to: the note of the Powers, stating! that the proceeds of the £5,000,- 000 loan will be expended' according to the conditions imposed by the governments and bankers concerned with the loan.
The; most important of these conditions} is the one regarding the disbanding of superfluous Chinese troops, which is to be carried out under! that the demand for supervision is merely talk.
It is certain that no preparation has been made by Peking for disbanding superfluous troops, and that none will be made until force is brought to bear upon the Government by the concerted action of the Powers that made the demands. We have not seen (or heard) of any organization being effected by the Powers to supervise the disbandment, and the lack of such an organization confirms the officials in their belief that there will be no supervision. So far the public has heard nothing from cither side of the manner in which the disbandment and supervision of disbandment is to be carried out. Is it possible that the Powers have tried to save their foreign supervision. face by excusing the loan upon question as to how far, and in Tt is now la) ihe basis that they have brought what manner, supervision of the Chinese armies is to be undertaken. the Peking Government to its knees by merely demanding that the Chinese armies be disbanded?-—
Force, tag Onty Way.
We have heard, in the past, of demands pressed upon the Peking Government by the Powers which, we believed at the time, would be} taken seriously by the Government, but to our surprise, this was not the case. Observers must give up expecting anything from a mere presentation of a forma] demand upon Peking to do this or that. Experience should have taught us by now that it is time wasted to present demands unless the Powers really intend to enforce them. Millions of dollars have been hi rowed during the last eight yea for disbandment purposes, but have seen the provincial armies rapidly increase in numbers in spite of Peking's promise to have them reduced.
The mere fact that the Powers have demanded from the Chinese Government a compliance with their demands that the superfluous troops be disbanded, and the agreement officially expressed to the Powers by Peking to the demands made, mean nothing.
We have not yet heard of any money having been paid to the Chinese Government out of the new loan, and it is sincerely to be d that none will be advanced until the machinery required for disbandment purposes is actually in working order. The militarists already believe that they have won a victory over the Powers in securing their support for the loan, and if we carelessly allow them to spend the proceeds of the loan without exacting a strict com-Pliance with the conditions imposed, our respective Governments will again be subject to the ridicule of the officials of China. It is absolutely necessary that no funds should be handed over to the Government until arrangements have been made for the supervision of its expenditure according to the terms of the agreement made for the loan.
The Chinese Government does not, as a fact, expect supervision of the disbandment of its soldiers, and many believe that they will not be disappointed in their hope The Chinese know the Chinese better than any foreigner can know them, and the Chinese have stated over and over again that the Government will never disband its superfluous troops until forced to do so by the Powers. The average Chinese man on the street merely smiles when we tell him that China is to disband her armies because the Powers have asked her to do so, and that she has agreed to do so. There is not an official in Peking to-day who takes the demand of the Powers seriously, and unless something is done to show that the demand upon China was made in earnest, Peking will not turn its hand' to do anything. No matter how long the average foreigner lives in this country, he seems unable to!varn anything about the..rinese from experience. In some cases he may understand the Chinese, but finds it convenient to hide his knowledge of Chinese officialdom, believing this to be the "line of least resistance." At any rate, it is to be hoped that these foreigners who are responsible will not again accept the promise of Peking to disband her armies and leave it to the officials to disband, as it suits their pleasure, A General once said that it was the easiest thing in the world to disband a division of soldiers in China; all that was needed being a sheet of paper and a brush. He stated that a few spare half hours spent in paper disbandment pleased Peking, and fooled the foreigner. In his mind it was evident that the two essentials were to please Peking and to deceive the foreigner.
There are many divisions of soldiers on paper, and we do not doubt that more than 20 per cent. of China's armies is on paper. It would not be a difficult matter for the Government and the Tuchuns to disband 20 per cent. of their armies without dismissing one soldier from the ranks. Consequently if the Powers are going to lend money to China for a "paper and brush" disbandment, there is no good to be served by the loans made.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.