"L can't help reaching the con clusion that Ross was happy in the the U.S. Court on Thurs the action of Ross v. the "China Press," in which plaintiff asked for $50,000 alleged damages for libel, The libellous statement complaineii of appeared in that journal on] January 8, 1025, and was as fot-
Fong Wel-soong, the enced to-d time clearing the elie dearer, Zia.
Mr. 'P. Faison appeared for plaintiff, Mr. S. Fessenden for defendants.
Continuing, his Honour said: let it ride in hopes that the "China Press" would be mulcted of greater damages if be did not demand an apology. Plaintiff does not appear from the evidence to have lost anything in the way of position in business or in a social standing, nor does he appear to be in a woree situation than he was six monthe £0, long before the alleged iibelloas tide appeared. But damages must be adequate and this Court, sitting as judge and jury, must determine the amount (defendants have admitted the libellous article) and from all facts concerned, if the Court awards $300 the award will be adequate, The judgment of the Court is then that plaintiff should recover M.$300 with costs of the action."
In his opening remarks, nis Honour stated that the difficulties of the Court had been greatly lessened by the frank admission counsel for defendants that damages er se, were due to plaintiff. Judge Purdy' then selected the latter three kinds of damages for his first consideration, punitive or ex. emplary, followed by special damages and then actual, 'A jury, he went on to say, would jot be allowed to award punitive damages auloss something calle: for punishment or penalties, suggested that there was nothing malicious in the article, for accord ing to the evidence neither staff or editor had ever heard of Ross prior to the publication of th article. 'The reporter, an intelligent and capable young man, who had had seven years' experience, found Ross's name mentioned in the Mixed] Court report, and used a rather unfortunate word and by innuendo friends of Ross might think he had been assisted in tracking down the: acendaries by fessed criminal Now Tors comes there whatsoever, 4 convict would something derogatory of the mai who brought him to justice," continued Judge Purdy, "It seems me there' is no ground to find the 'China Press' subject to liability under punitive damages.'
The Beer Contract Under the item of special damages his Honour went on to say that, according to the evidence, Plaintiff was about to. enter into contract whereby he might sell large quantity of beer at a profit of $1. per case (10,000 cases). This was: in October. But during" October, November and December until December 22, 1922, nothing was done, at which time he met Davis and they submitted " memorandust of agreement to Mr. Teesdale. But, hig Honour continued, they did not know that Mr. Teesdale over received it, for he had not been called to give evidence, "I am satisfied that no such thing ever took place," Judge Purdy stated. "Tam sus-Pleious of the whole contract,'
"It is on that charge and claim that this Court is asked to. give damages of $50,000, for speculative Erofits on possible sales of beer. find that plaintiff is not entitled to cial damages on account of the Davis's Bvidence mis to denying these special Sudge Purdy intimated seemed strange to him that two men who had known each other for 20 years and had formed a business and arranged their names together in the "North-China" Hong List, should have such a conversa-tien' as stated in evidence. Davis, according to the evidence, waited for a retraction in the paper. Ross said he went to see Davis id Davis said to him, continued in Honour, 'I sce you are mixed up in an arson case.' "But," said Judge Purdy, "Ross did not say what he answered, Wouldn't. Ross say, 'Why Davis, that is a falaehood, and I will' ask the "China Press" to retract it, and they will? Can a court of justice hear a story Tike that, and believe it?"
Turning to the subject of actual damage his Honour said that he could not see any evidence of humiliation or damage to plaintiff's reputation, but as damages must be adequate and defendant had mitted the article to be libellous would award M.$300,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.