Ir is with considerable regret that we have felt it necessary to refer at some length to the unsatisfactory condition of affairs in respect of the public utilities in the French Concession adminis. tered by the Compagnie Fran-caisse de Tramways et d'Eclairage Electriques. But M. Chapeaux's exposition, following as it does upon the ultimatum of the French Municipal Council, makes it necessary that those ratepayers in the French Concession who are not acquainted with the language should be posted with details of a matter which very nearly affects them. It was in March of this year that we voiced the general discontent that was felt in the Concession with the supply of electric light then given by the Company. It was, from the very nature of things, a superficial survey of the situation as it then was. That the statements then made were in the main accurate is evident from the fact that subsequently the French Municipal Council, who had already made repeated protests on the matter, took it up and appointed a commission to inquire into the whole questions and it was upon their report that the ultimatum of October 9 was issued. Briefly stated, the allegations levelled against the French Company are three in number: they have failed to keep pace with the times, the tramway system is no longer of a magnitude justified by the size of the district in-which it operates, and the supply of water and electric light by the Company itself is wholly insufficient to meet the requirements of a municipality from which the company has obtained a very rich monopoly.
In justice to the monopolists it may be said that whatever plans they might have had for the exten-ion of their undertakings were incapable of execution during the five years of war. The difficulty of obtaining material was enhanced by the fact that, had it been delivered in France, it would still have been practically impossible to have transported it to Shanghai. But the war ended in 1918, and even if the French Municipal Council were prepared to wait during 1919 for something to be done, their patience could not be expected to last through another year. That is, in fact, what has happened and it was not until the Council had issued their letter of October 9 that information reached Shanghai as to what the Company had planned for the futare. Whether their programme will meet the requirements of the French Municipal Council is a matter into which we do not at present intend to go. That it comes a great deal too late is the main criticism to be advanced against it. The Company has made a great deal of money out of its monopoly. The profits for 1919 amounted to Frs. 19,000,000 on a total capitalization of Frs. 8,000,000, and that with three wholly inadequate services, It may be, and should be, that, out of such immense sums as have acerned to the company in profits, provision has been made for those extensions which the development' of the French Concession rightly demands, not for further development but for the efficient supply of the whole district as it at present stands. And if this has been done it should convey a modicum of satisfaction which must be discounted by the delay for causes which operated as much against similar undertakings in the International Settlement as in the French Concession.
It is clear that the anxiety of the French Municipal Council over the water supply during last summer is not such as should by sheer necessity be caused again, nor should the ratepayers as a whole be subject to the inconveni lence that inadequate systems of public utilities carry in their train. It is for.this reason that the French Municipal Council deserve the congratulations and wholehearted support of the community in the action they have taken. Tt is possible that they will not have to proceed to the extreme step contemplated by their letter, Such, probably, would be very far from their desires, but they realize, possibly better than do these responsible in Paris for the management of the Company, that the needs of a growing Concession such as the French cannot consistently be ignored. That the Company will awaken to the serious state of affairs in Shanghai and will do their utmost to er-range for such extensions in their works as will enable them to fulfil the contract under which they secured the rich monopoly they hold, is the least that can be expected of them. By purchasing from the Electricity Department of the International Settlement, 70 per cent..of the current they are supposed to manufacture they are certainly not keeping to their bargain; by failure to maintain an adequate water supply they lay themselves open to the same reproach. In these circumstances it is to be hoped that the Company will despatch a representative to Shanghai with full powers to negotiate with the Municipal Council, to discuss their future programme and to enter into such agreements as are necessary for the greater efficiency of the three services in question.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.