The Archive · 1920

A Settlement Day Law Suit

Supreme Court Decision — In H. M. Supreme Court on

Saturday, his Honour Judge Skinner Turner gave his decision in the case of J. A. Hayes v. Davies & Brooke, heard the Court on Thursday. Plaintiff entered a motion to restrain defendants from dealing in certain property otherwise than in accordance with an order of the Mixed Court, in which judgement was given for plaintiff for nearly four lakhs of taels against Kwauh Yui-teen. There is a question as to whether Kwauh remains the owner of the property in question, or has, through his agents, Messrs. Davies & Brooke, disposed of his rights therein to two other Chinese.

Mr. E. L. Hartopp represented plaintiff. Mr. H. Lipson Ward defendants, and Mr. 8. H. McKean the two Chinese who now claim that the beneficial interest in the property has been transferred to themselves.

His Lordship, in giving judgement, said:—This case has caused me considerable difficulty. It is a claim

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account