"Your letter of July 29, enclosing correspondence with the' Shanghai L.A, was considered by my Rules Conynitteo at their meeting Weld on September 29.
"Tam instructed to say that on the facts stated by you, the umpire was at fault in not enforcing the provisions of Rule 28, and if you had made a protest at the time he could have had no option but to award the match to you. Seeing, however, that you: made no protest at the time, you placed yourself in the position of consenting to the delay, and that is doubtless the reason why the Committee awarded the match to your opponents.
"The proper procedure in a case of this kind is to make a protest to the umpire and to demand that the opponents shall proceed immedi rely with the match. If he does not order the opponents to continue playing, then the other side should insist on formal notice being taken of the protest, and then complete the match under' protest. At the con. clusion of the match the facts then should be reported to the appropriate authority for settlement.
"A copy of this letter is being sent to the Secretary of the Shang-
For the guidance of local players and off jin the future, the UTA. judgment might be set out in summary form as follows (1) The umpire undoubtedly was at fault, (2) The protest should be made en the field of play and before resuming the game.
(3) If the umpire ignores the first appeal and later insists on play being resumed, the protesting player should continue only under protest and later controlling body for a decistor The suggestion made when the case first was Feviewed also might be repeated, namely, that it might helpful in cases of importance—though not, of course, in all—if the committee would: publish the reasons for ruch decisions as it makes on.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.