The Archive · 1905

Saw Reports

M. SUPREME COURT

Shanghai, 6th: December.

Before Sir Havintany "pk SivewAnnz, Jenny Morxis (carrying.on. business 5

Moxris'&: Co.) Waisetock-& Co.-

'Mz. Wilkinson" submitted that a" pér-son making a contract with another "was led to know all the' material facts which would influen this case plaintiff: applied" for damages. "Ho hid alrendy mentioned four "claims, or possibilities © of lai which'his oliout had. Coiuisel submitted man coulil recover' for thisroprossitation and slander. " He conteriddd the Ts.

10,000 claimed tangible, "His Lordsbiip said it might be tangible but plaintiff could not towch'it, Counsel submitted that ho' really had hot to deal with that quostion'at all.:'Tt had boon proved that the directors of tue amalgamated company nnd those of thd old cond pany werd prepared strongly to récommond plaintiff the sui' of "Pis.".10,000, 'That fact was proved by: the payment of the Tls. 18,280. "At the boginaing Mr. Morris'had 'a very tangible clair to'! 10,000. According to the directors themselves he was paid Tls. 18,280 without the ut of any shareholders at all. It assary for him to deal with the ion' whether plaintiff could" hav recovered the Tls. 10,000. Mr. Mor had made it very clear to his 'Lordship that' he had the four claims nientionéd in his mind. Legally he had oily s'etaiin for three months' wages, and ho still. had this' claim. 'Plaintiff named. Tis.'15,000 as the amount he wanted' to be paid from the Tug Boat'Co. The Tug Be ©o.. hi fect right to' dissolve and" divide its assets. 'The claim: of Tls. 16,000 against the Tug 'Boat' was for retirement, but' ho shad' giv evidence; which the records bote' out, that he°was -claiming a larger sum regard to other matters included' in the retirement. When Mr. "Morris claimed the Tls. 15,000 he did not know whether hewes going. to be' the agent' or not. Whatever sum the directors of the old company would' have recommended tie sharehélders"to pay; Mr. Morn claimed was the sum he hid.béen deprived of by defendants' action, 'The: next claim' was against the-amalgamated "ombpany. for non-intetferénde.

Tu the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account