The Archive · 1923

The Police Trial

Apr. 26.

THERE can be no member of the foreign community, we think, certainly none among the British, who will not experience deep sense of relief that the jury have acquitted Detective-Inspector Gabbutt and Detective-Sergeant Balchin of the horrid charges brought against them. For those charges affected the prestige of all Western peoples, and if they had been upheld, there was no one who would not have felt that the civilization on which we pride ourselves had been besmirched. And let it further be emphasized that the jury did not arrive at their decision lightly. Six full days has the trial lasted, not to mention those spent on the police court inquiry, during which every available scrap of evidence was brought to light and thoroughly tested. It would have been impossible to hold a more searching and impartial inquiry.

We believe we may say, without conceit, that the British people have some reputation for a sense of justice, not undeserved. It will, we believe, it certainly should, go without saying that the question of nationality did not count for the weight of one hair with the jury. No one can have served on a_ British jury without being impressed by the intensely serious mind in which they approach their task. The man who in private life appears to care for nothing but fun, frolic and good-fellowship becomes a different creature in the jury box and he would rather find a friend guilty than, where the slightest doubt might arise, appear guilty himself of prejudice. In Shanghai, moreover, juries are generally of a high class, composed of men of good education accustomed in the course of their own business to scrutinize facts and weigh opinions. If any possible consideration of bias could have entered into this trial, it must have been against the accused. For, as the Judge observed, directly accusations of cruelty to man or beast arise, our sympathies are all instinctively on the victim's side.

The facts of the trial have been so fully reported that there is no need, even if there were space, to review them further here. But one point may be emphasized. There was no direct evidence against Gabbutt

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account