The following letter is written by one who makes no attempt to con-coal his sympathies and if the original comments to which he replies were too severe, it is possible that tha present writer ts. too enthusiastic.° Speaking generally, for ux have no first-hand knowledge of conditions on the U. BE. &., the truth in such matters lies probably somewhere midway. But the Chinese are so often adversely criticized for their management of things that we welcome any opportunity of bestowing commendation where it ts due.
Harbin, March 30.
During the past three months there have appeared in your columns two articles dealing with the Chinese Eastern Railway that are to say the least of it both misleading and incorrect in the essential. In justice to all those who are now connected with this Railway and irrespective of nationality or creed and as one who knows intimately past and present conditions on this much criticized iron-road, I am sending you the following facts that are indisputable.
Your correspondent in his letter in the "N. C. Daily News" of March 14 states that he had an interview with "one of the Soviet representatives' here in Harbin, who, it is not surprising, would not let his name be published seeing the ignorance of his views advanced ubout.the O, E. R. practically been confiscated by the.To say that the C. E. R. has Chinese, and to compare Russia's position with what America's would be, if the Panama Canal were seized by another Power whilst she was busy with repulsing other nations, is of course absurd. careful study of the Agreemerts, has been made for the convenience of the Chinese travelling and shipping public who are greatly in excess of Russians or any other nationals. Hitherto through ignorance of language the Chinese have frequently suffered' all kinds of inconveniences and mishaps and have been swindled in numerous ways. As the Railway is a commercial enterprise it is unfair to say that to put these agents on the line is merely a political move on the part of the Chinese Directors.
The article entitled Chinese Exactions.on the O. R. which appeared) in. your columns at the latter end of December was written by a Mr, de Bunting (not Mr. Bunting,'who is the Harbin representative of the Baldwin Locomotive Works).. Many of the statements made in the article are not only misleading but cast an undeserved slur upon the -Chineso Directors of the Railway.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.