The Archive · 1923

MAJOR HILTON JOHNSON'S BVIDENCE

Major Hilton Johnson, Deputy of Police, gave evidence as to an inquiry by the police authorities when the case against Loh had been dismissed. Giving particulars of Gabbutt's service, Witness-stated that ho had been three times commended for the arrest of robbers and, in September of last year, highly commended and given six months' advancement in class for the arrest of- highway robbers. There was one minor disciplinary offence against him, one of "absence from barracks." There was no disdiplinary report against Balchin.

His Lordship—We know now that from time to time there are charges of torture made against the police in the Mixed Court, and that a circular was issucd.—Yes.

Can you tell me what is the meaning of the last paragraph in that circular: "This memorandum is issued in full knowledge and appreciation" of the extreme difficulties police officers have in dealing with criminals locally."—I can explain that. When I first came to this. fored about 15 years ago I was in charge of the Chinese branch for about four years, and had many inquiries in which Chinese were concerned. Since then, as Deputy Commissioner, I have attended many inquiries in which Chinese are concerned, and I know the intense provocation that can he given to ncople whose duty it is to find out the truth from Chinese of the criminal classes. Armed robbery being the great trouble in Shanghai, it very often happens that a gang of five or six are known to be operating. Perhaps two are captured. It is then a question often net-of hours but of moments as to how to get the others before they get away; and if the two under arrest will not give details, it is intensely irritating to know that under your hand, so to speak, there are four more and you cannot get them for want of just a little information. And that is what I refer to. The meaning of the paragraph was that, in spite of this feeling, the thing had got to be done in the proper way.

NO LIMIT TO CROSS-EXAMINATION, Do you consider that tha proper way is to take a man out of the cells at midnight and. cross-examine, after he has already been cross-examined twicti?—Well, there is no limit to cross-examination, sir.

Here is a charge of thoft. The man has been examined twice and has admitted it. Is there out' justification for pulling him out again at midnight for a third cross-examination?—There is in every police force what ig known as the third degree.. Actually, in America—yDo you approve of it here? That is what I am asking you May I explain? 7 Cannot you answer my question?—Certainly. I approve of intéhsive questioning ta any extent. - 2 You don't, approve, then, of what Mr. Armstrong and Inspector Mackenzie said about the treat-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account