The Archive · 1923

The Statute of Frauds

Of course, where an essential feature of a contract is omitted, it cannot be regarded as a contract in writing, though it might still be an "instrument"? within the meaning of the Extraterritorial Remedial Code. The Supreme Court has held, ¢.g. that a memorandum is insufficient under the Statute of Frauds where the name of but one party is mentioned. But each of these instruments specifies, not only the names of both parties, but the subject matter, the consideration and the undertaking. The fact that some of the terms are technical, and may require explanation to those not engaged in that particular line of business, does not prevent these instruments from satisfying the Statute of Frauds. Indeed, this Court has already held such instruments to be sufficient under that Statute and there is authority for the view that an instrument sufficient thereunder, constitutes also'a written contract within the Statute of Limitations.

Defendant's main reliance is upon a decision to the effect that an action on an implied warranty of title is not governed by that clause in the Statute of Limitations relating to written contracts, although the original transaction was evidenced by a bill of sale. But here the obligation to deliver is not umphed. Delivery. 1s specified for a fixed date over the signature of defendant, and while the language is terse to the point of being cryptic, we may take judicial notice of the fact that it is well understood by those engaged in that particular line of business. These instruments are certainly fuller in phraseology than ordinary cheques, but, contrary to the writer's contention when practising at the Bar, Courts have held such instruments to be written contracts within the language of the Statute of Limitations. It has also been held that an account "audited and approved" and "'certified to be correct" is sufficient to bring the instrument within such language, though no undertaking to pay is otherwise expressed. The same effect has been given ta a memorandum reading: "I acknowledge the above account to be just."

Nor is there even unanimity in the decisions to the effect that if part of the agreement sued upon is implied it is governed by that clause of the Statute of Limitations applying to unwritten contracts. The following instrument is certainly less full than those here sued upon

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account