The Archive · 1923

A Denial of Liability

Careful consideration of the facts of the case leads to the conclusion that no liability for damages can be predicated of the Chinese Government. In view, however, of the circumstances of their capture, as well as the suffering and indignities sustained by them in consequence, I have the honour to inform you that the Chinese Government desire, of their accord, to do, in the fullest measure possible, what is equitable in the way of reparation for the foreign victims of this unfortunate incident. For this purpose they are ready to accept as the basis of classification and assessment the three categories of damages, "A," "B," and "OE," outlined in Your Excellency's Note under reply. The reason for the progressive ifierease in the amount of compensation from week to week for captives during the period of the captivity, however, does not seem clear, since the delay in their release was due to the adoption of negotiation with the bandits as the safest means of effecting their release, a course which was followed in harmony with the express wishes of the Diplomatic Body.

As_ regards what is described in Your Excellency's Note as "supplementary indemnities" for individual cases, they appear to be in the nature of indirect, remote or consequential damages, and the Chinese Government do not feel themselves in a position to include them in the basis of

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account