The Archive · 1923

Strange Feature of the Knife

Opening the case for the prosecution, Mr, Wilkinson defined the judicial meaning of the charge of murder in British law, and proceeded to state that the weapon in the case was a knife. The evidence for the Crown would be that the prisoner and two other men were sitting together in the foc'sle head on the starboard side. One of those men was now dead, the other was the accused man, and the third a witness, Abdul Raman. Prisoner came wp and spoke to deceased. Abdul Raman heard a'shout, saw a knife and thereupon ran off to give the alum. If there was question as to whether the knife that would be produced was the one used, it was that a Health Department analyst had found no human blood on it. It was an interesting and curious fact, and might be due to the difficulties of the Department in getting more supplies of serum from Home.

It certainly was one' of those things that were very difficult to understand.—It might he taken as a sort of warning as to the weight to be attached and sometimes not to be attached to circumstantial evidence. Accused in the presence of many persons, however, the Crown would say, struck deceased' with a deadly weapon. It was not for him (the Crown Advocate) or the jury to concern themselves as to why the prisoner did this, for according to the medical evidence and other witnesses deceased had died from the wound. It was the painful duty of the prosecution to show that the prisoner was guilty. of the crime of murder, Mr. E. W. H. Carpenter, of Machinnon, Mackenzie & Ca. agents for the P. & O. S. N. Ca., examined by Mr. Mansell-Reece, said that in consequence of a letter he received he made arrang cements for the landing of a corpse.

John Evans, master of the tug Gutzlaff, and a Chinese ambulance man, gave evidence, respectively, as to taking the body on board the tug and depositing it at the public Mortuary Dr. N. Hay Bolton, who performed the post-mortem, stated that deceased appeared to be about 25, and had been dead from 12 to 2 hours. Describing the wounds, witness said there was one superficial cut above the leit knee; a punctured wound between the 9th and 10th ribs on the left side, about I}in. long, in direction downwards and inwards; an incised wound on the left side of the face, just below the lower jaw, about half an inch deep; and a wound on the left palm puncture ing the hand. All the wounds were on the left side of the body, and might be said to be fairly haemorrhage and peritonitis. Examining a clasp knife, witness said he thought it might have been the type of instrument used.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account