The Archive · 1926

U.S. Law? John W. Maloney and_ Richard'

Barrett, charged with trafficking in farms by the American authorities were released on Saturday on thei once having signed personal bond for G. $300. Mr. N. E. Lurton in the U. S. Court heard the arguments of counsel, ar. F. J. Schuhl, for the defence, and My. D. Rodger, for the prosecution. The has been set for hearing on June 30, at which time Mr. L. G. Husar, Dist has Just returned from the North, will conduct the ease for the US. Government.

Tr will be recalled that accused were arrested on Wednesday at 4 Yala Road, by Det-Inspr. Mace Dermott and Inspr. MeKenzie of Hongkew station, the police party finding a pistol, a rifle and mea than 4, c00 rounds of ammunition on the premises. When they were brought up for trial, Mr. E. T. Maitland, Police Prosecutor, asked for a remand, pending Mr, Husar's return, On Saturday Mr, Schuhl made the startling assertion that he did not believe Americans could be charged with trafficking in arms in (China, unless they imported them into China or exported them from America. The only possible charge that could be placed against his clients was possessing arms without a licence. Referring to Judge Purdy's recent ruling in the Beardsley case, when he stated that Americans could only be tried under American law, the Distret of Columbia Code in preference, Mr. Schuhl intimated that his clients were guilty of no crime. Mr, Schuhl added that his Honour ecepted the municipal by-laws his eorstruction of law for Americans in Shangh:

ug further into the case, counsel cited the treaty of 1884; hich provided that Americans tri in contraband should be dealt with by the China authorities, out any, protection from the Aman Government.

This, of course, coursd added, had been nullified by provisions of traterritoriality.

Mr, Rodger pointed out that one! accused was charged with consi "ence. Schuhl, however, said which' was a very serious

that if there was no' original cums, there euuld be 10 conspiracy.

The Court sustained the proseeumand set the trial for June 30,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account