Action Against North China Cold Storage Ca. for Price of Consignment of Cattle In the United States Court for China en_'Luesday Judge: Lobinglor gave his decision in an action at the instance of the Mao Tung Products Ca. against the North China Cold Storage Ca. Inc. In this action Mr, R. T. Evans appeared for the plaintiffs and Mr. rt. E. Simmang for the defendants.
In giving judgment his Honour said This is an action to recover thr price of certain cattle furnished by plaintiff to defendant in pursuance of a written contract. The latter called for 1,000 head and it is admitted that plaintiff delivered 577. These were not all delivered at the same time, nor within the limits prescribed by the contract, but they were nevertheless accepted by defendant, and the amount due thereon fixed at Mex. $26,313.73 upon which de fondant paid the sum of Mex. $10,000 leaving a balance due of $16,313.73.
The main controversy in the case concerns defendant's claim of damages by way of set-off for ihe undelivered portion. Of these it is undisputed that 260 head were obtained by defendant at the same market from which plaintiff was purchasing and were shipped by defendant on the same steamer which carried those accepted from plaintiff. There is no evidence or claim that this consignment occasioned defendant any greater expense than—the cattle received directly from plaintiff and 1t would seem that these 2e0 head should, therefore, he deducted from the shortage chargeable to plaintiff. This would leave 163 head unaccounted for and upon these damages, if any, must be assessed.
In a subsequent contract entered into by plaintiff with defendant and a third party. Okura & Ca., it was agreed that the latter should "Ba at liberty to go into the market and purchase an the best terms sufficient cattle for their own contracts and any question of damages against Mao Tung Products Company shall be discussed and assessed hereafter.""
Even without this agreement defendant would have been entitled to purchase in the open market on the best obtainable terms and to have charged against plaintiff any excess of the market price over the contract price. But the payment of such difference. of course, needs to be established by clear and competent evidence which, in this instance, we must find has not been produced. Unsigned copies of correspondence purporting to have passed between Okura & Ca. and a vendor known as Shotai-ya are offered in evidence. but they, of course, are
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.