Grain, sitting as the Full Court, on Wednesday gave judgment in the appeal cage of A. & T. Nastashevsky, a Harbin merchant and his wife, v. the Far Eastern Insurance''Company. The decision of Judge Peter Grain in favour of the insurance company was upheld, and an intimation was given that further proceedings may be taken.
Mr. Tycho Wing appeared for appellants, and Mr. H. Lipson Ward for respondents.
In giving judgment, Sir Skinner Turner said: This is an appeal from a decision of his Honour Judge Grain, sitting without a jury. The action was brought upon an award which assessed the amount payable under a fire insurance policy issued by the defendant company in the event of their liability being established.. The defendant company pleaded various defences, =the principal one being the existence of a condition precedent which had een broken, and fraud. The learned trial Judge found both these defences proved and gave judgment for the defendant with costs. Against that judgment this appeal has been brought and it is urged that the facts show there was no breach of any condition precedent, and secondly that there was no evidence of any fraud at all.
The fire took place in Harbin on May. 29, 1921, and the whole place (a tobacco factory and offices) seems to have been destroyed: in addition to the goods, etc. covered by the policy, all the books were destroyed, save one which was with the plaintiff in Japan. Certain payments have been made in respect of buildings and machinery under the policy, but the defendants, liable under the policy only for the cost price of goods and materials, contend that they are not liable for these.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.