The Ruhr occupation can also be considered from the point of view of a productive pledge, to be worked by the occupying authorities in default of official Reparation payments by the German Government. This is the official French viewpoint. But see what it means. It is not merely a bare occupation to exercise pressure on tha German Government. 16 is a direct exploitation of German territory, entirely unprovided for in tha Versailles 'I'reaty. Tt cannot squared with the Reparation provisions of the Treaty. It means the substitution by France of her own scheme for that which is contained in the Treaty.
If the agreements now being concluded between General De-goutte and the Ruhr industrialists were to come up before the Reparation Commission for confirmation, the legal issue would at once be raised, as the Commission can only carry out the provisions of the Treaty, and have no other authority or power. The French hate the word "revision," and yet they have actually begun the revision of the Versailles Treaty! They are enforcing a settlement outside and different from that provided for m the Treaty. They have the congratulations of all those who hate the Treaty. They have begun a process which will go very far. And it is as well for the world at once to recognize the far-reaching significance of tha French initiative.
But there is a far graver aspect from which the Ruhr occupation can be considered, and will more and more come to be considered in the future. In_the recent correspondence the British Govern-mont have stated their view. that the occupation is illegal. With all their authority and responsibility they have declared before the world that the Ruhr occupation is a breach of the Versailles Treaty on the part of France and Belgium. They have asked that the question should be decided by the Supreme Court of Appeal among the nations by the High Court of International Justice. Their request has not been granted, and will not be granted, for the simple reason that there can be no doubt in the matter. Ifthe action of France and Belgium is right and legal under the Treaty, then any one signatory of the Treaty can at any time allege a breach of the Treaty by Germany, and thereupon proceed to invade her territory, and claim to do so under the Treaty: Such an interpretation of the Peace Treaty is on the face of it unfair and wrong.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.