The Archive · 1926

Counsels' Summing

Mr, MeDonald then addressed the Court on behalf of accused and brought up several points for consideration. Witnesses, he said, who were not called by the prosecution at the previous hearing could easily agree on their story, especially in! connexion with the version of the! arrest since they had ample opportunity to talk it over, but their stories regarding the tea-shop varied. One man said that he had conversation accused and the last witness said the same thing' but, When questioned at length, admitted that he conversed with him. If accused had been in possession of farms, contended counsel, he would not have shouted "Robbers!" According to his client, the charge was 1 frame-up, the pistols were planted fon him. He told the story to the police and told the same story to the Court. His suggestion was that the detective tried to extort some money from him. Even during cross. examination, his evidence was not shaken. As' to the Sikh constable, this man was some distance away ind didn't see the search—nor did he see the parcels, which Note wrapped in white paper, There was some doubt, contended counsel, and accused was entitled to the benefit of tis and so counsel would ask the Court to dismiss the case, Mr. Maitland, in reply, said that some of the men who made the arrest were rather stout and tall and it was possible that, owing: to this, the Sikh constable did than a year and he was not wealthy so it was hard to see why the detective and his seconds should try to extort money from The detective's record was then produced. and-Mr. McDonald asked for permission to ack one of the witnesses if he had ever been convicted. Ho Foong-we was then recalled and, upon being questioned by Mr. McDonald, admitted that he!: had once been sentenced to six months? imprisonment.

After considering the. case engtl, the Court adjourned the heating.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account