The Archive · 1926

A New Policy in China

Tr is curious how what is called the spirit of the age can act with identical results upon quite different natures in widely separated localities. During a recent holiday absence, the present writer conceived certain ideas for a new policy in China. Without his mentioning them to anyone those: ideas were one day suggested to him as the only practical solution of the West's many, problems in this country. On his return to Shanghai, the same expedients were put forward in his hearing by three persons representing totally' different miliewx. And now. again they appear in the long, and thoughtful article, which we commence to-day, by Mr. Rodney Gilbert, who moreover says that! ]various persons in the Legations are impressed with the scheme as offering the only practical jeourse, and that it is even being debated in the Foreign Offices! fof Europe and Americ The idea is nothing else than that which was sketched in last} Friday's leading article "China Not One But Many," the policy suggested being that the Power should recognize China for what she actually is, should withdraw recognition from Peking and ideal directly with the local authorities as the heads of the independent states they are, For! Mr. Gilbert's treatment, of the! subject, with its extremely interesting account of the Peking! viewpoint, which naturally differs in soma essentials from that of other centres, readers must bbe asked to wait until to-morrow Meanwhile the preliminary e: position of events leading up to the Powers' reluctant acceptance of the total failure of the line they have hitherto been taking' may be commended to general attention, Most interesting of all, perhaps, is Mr. Gilbert's assertion that in actual fact recognition been withdrawn! from Peking, disappearing last] April when the Kuominchun left the city and Tuan Chi-jui was forcibly retired from the seat of Chief Executive. That may be 80, but nobody knows it. Only a month ago the British Minister appeared to be recognizing something in Peking in indicting the Wanhsien note to the Waichiaopu. And, as Mr. Gilbert say: the Chinese people do not derstand that recognition has; been withdrawn. It is absolutely essential thet they should. A step so full of possible good for China ought to be taken in the most formal and public way. So long as there is any pretence that a Government sits in Peking which the Powers recognize, so long will military and political cliques scramble for possession of Peking, for the prestige) that hangs about it, and for the emoluments to which that} prestige can be turned. Conversely, if recognition is withdrawn,' the consequent shattering of "face," the final explosion' of the Chu' Chao-hsins and all their fairy-tales will be so tremendous, that Chinese political circles will not rest until they' have got recognition back.

And then comes the question, What sort of Government would the Powers recognize? 'The first consideration here is that it should be such a one as would be good for China, able to reduce armies, maintain peace and put down bandits. 'Too much stress is laid' on the requirements of trade, with indeed good intentions, but in the upshot lending, colour to the propaganda of the foreigners' "imperialistic" designs. It was emphasized in a leading article last week that whatever injustice, loss and ill-eatment foreigners may suffer in China is a mere drop in the [bucket compared with the sufferings of the Chinese people. And jit is further to be emphasized that those sufferings practically never enter into the thoughts of their so-called rulers. Take, for example, the recent attempt by a party in Chekiang to invade and capture Shanghai. Mercifully it seems to have failed. But even the attempt was enough cause great anguish of mind and personal inconvenience to crowds of humble folk, who fled with one accord into the Settlement for safety. Of the far greater hardships of the people in other regions our letters from ithe interior speak frequently and eloquently. Nothing could have [been more wanton than the Ché- kiang coup, except any of the wars which have rent China in the past two or three years. These things must cease and it becomes abundantly clear that without pressure from outside they never will, At the Washington Conference the Powers Jaccepted a moral responsibility for the state of China, Their good intentions came to naught because they were based upon wrong premises. But that does not lessen the responsibility, it increases it, and there is still time to put the premises right,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account