Interesting, Argument by Counsel in the Mixed Court: Brazilian Citizen with a Father from Ningpo: Some Old Precedents Cited At the Mixed Court on Wednesday Sefore Mr, Bensa, Brazilian Asses-[ or, and Magistrate Li, Charles Wiliam Zee brought a claim against Sung Kuang-dee for $1,500, with terest and. costs.
Mr, E, Y, B. Kiang represented he plaintiff and Messrs. H. D. Rodger and H, R. Snyder appear-for the defence.
At the outset of the case, Mr. Rodger seid that this was a motion hat the case should be set before "he usual Chinese civil court. and of before the Brazilian Asvessor, pon the ground that the plaintiff vas not a Brazilian citizen. The {reatest importance was attached the motion as it was quite apparent that the man who now eallhimself a, Brazilian subject "ould quite possibly have deceived me Brazilian authorities in the same measure as_others had done who wished to claim foreign nationality ud. protection although they were: hinese and subject to the jurisdiction of the International Mixed Court. In foreign civil ease 5878 Peng Han-chin v, Mok Kai-kong), 3 motion was made for the case he be struck out, continued counsel, 3 the defendant claimed to be a Gritish subject. Messrs.. Martin ind Yui decided that, if a Chinese vas_born in Europe, he became a foreign citizen under the laws of cathe country in which he was born, {he came to China, he again be-tame a Chinese citizen under Chin= se law. If a Chinese became a coreign subject he must first obtai certificate of denaturalization from Chinese Government before he. vag allowed to waive his Chinese} "citizenship and, if he had not got hat certificate, he still remained a Zhinese subject. In the ease in question, Mr. Rodger continued, the Jefendant was. put_ on security' and ease became n Chinese civil ease, though the defendant in that ease sug actually born in England. Ti og not only a rule of the Mixed urf, but of the Supreme Court of hina, and counsel thought the Seneh would agree with him that]
Mixed Court was governed by same individual and the man who the English courts treated as a British subject may by the French Neourts be treated as a French citizen, We found that to be the case during the war when many French people who were living in America and had American citizen-_ ship were claimed by the French Government.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.