The Archive · 1915

BR. W. Sexton v. 8. R. Price

His Honour gave judgement in this case, in which the—plaintiff claimed for the recovery of Tis, 16,000 on a non-nego-table note which he asserted was for money advanced and used by defendant for the purpose of opening a gambling house. The document, dated May 4, 1909, was a promise by defendant to pay to plaintiff thirty days from date Tls. 15,000 for value received. It was admitted, but defendant contended there was a mutual understanding that the note was not intended to operate as, or have the effect of, @ promissory note as between the parties thereto.

Defendant further contended that at the time the note was made plaintiff was indebted to him in a large sium of money on a running account, and the note given was only intended as @ receipt in res of this account. Further, it was contended for the defence that the account was settled by mutual consent on September 3, 1914, the note given being accordingly rendered void.

His Honour reviewed the ciroumstances of the partnership between the parties at the Alcazar and Alhambra, and observed that whichever version was accepted, there would seem to have been @ most peculiar and unusual course of dealing. The judgement concluded:

"On the whole we must find that the record contains evidence at least sufficient to shift to plaintiff the burden of proving the validity

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account