September 16.
Tue latest news of the progress of counsels at Peking contains a curious mixture of matter for sor row and matter for mirth. It ix hard to repress a smile in reading of the proposed establishment of a peerage school for the education of sons of princes and nobles. in their prospective duty as members of a Chinese House of Lords; when we remember what heated controversies are raging about the venerable heads of our own Upper Chamber while from any point of view the school, as suggested by Pao Hsi, Vice-President of the Board of Education, will appear no other than a cynical example of the art of putting cart before horse. But it is in the announcement that the date has practically been fixed, on which their Excellencies Wuang Ta-hsi and Yi Shih-mei shall start for Japan, Great Britain and Germany, respectively, that we may find most food for reflection, and regret. It was originally intended that princes of the blood should be sent abroad to study foreign constitutions with a view to what China might adopt for her own new regime. This course was abandoned; partly through fear of anarchists, a trivial piece of timidity which might have been safely dis regarded even if it were ever seriously felt; partly because the princes were suid to be needed to advise at Peking. But exception is not so much to be taken to the particular rank of Commissioners who gu, as to the fact that Commissioners are going at all. When the form that China's constitution should take was raised for discussion at Peking, Duke Tsui Tsch is said to have propounded Japan as a model; Chinese Ministers abroad und foreign trained officials suggested England; Yuan Shih-kai declared in favour of In this conflict of opinions, we read, the proposal to send Special Commissioners to study and report on the three named countries, " was eagerly seized upon by their Majesties: for "this will give Peking breathing time."
Even without the suggestion conveyed in the last sentence, it is only too apparent that the Throne to gain time; and, as panic at the lengths tow enthusiasm for reform have carried it, is falling back once more upon the known and comfortable paths of delay. The reform party is said to have the apper hand in Peking still: but it is plain that there is The H-C Werald and S. C. & C. much friction between the different groups in the Capital; and while we may hesitate to believe altogether in the reported impeachment of Yuan Shih-kai by Chang Chih-tung, which we quote to-day in another column, there is no doubt that serious differences of opinion exist between the two great ex-Viceroys, which cannot conduce to smoothness in the work of reformation. If, moreover, it is seriously deemed necessary for China to mould herself upon. the constitutions of either Great Britain or Germany, there must already he abundance' of stored information on the subject in Peking, more than sufficient for the Throne and its advisers to act upon. What. has become of the reports of the Chinese departments through Europe and America? What of Viceroy Tuan's lately published work on hi tions during that tour? But itis indeed questionable how far one country can adopt the constitution of another, whether ex bloc or only partially. "For constitutions grow in accordance with the de and instincts of the several nations to which they belong; and that which is natural and acceptable in one country may grotesque anon transplantation toan alien soil. It ix noticeable that, with all that has been heard of a constitution for China. there has been no mention of any scheme of. franchise: for which, indeed, the education of the people in no way fits them, even if any scheme of. popular representation could devised adequate to the needs of so vast a multitude. Yet franchise plays a vital part in the constitution of Great. and, though to a lesser degree, in that of German, The success with which Japan has adopted European ins tions is no analogy for what might be in China; since the Japanese possess an appetite and adaptability for experiment which certainly could not be attributed to the Chinexe. A truer analogy might be found in here political life, tinged by the pro-ion days, into the great camps of Liberilism and Conservatism, and depends in reality upon a series of groups gathered about individual states 'h men.
To impose a brand new and totally unfamiliar constitution upon any nation is somewhat parallel to the fallacy of State-provided charity ies: the more that is done for men the less they are inclined to do for themselves, and the recipients of a free gift are distressingly prone to use it ina manner quite the contrary of what the intended. "Whether the Chinese Commissioners remain three years in Europe or thirty, it is question able whether they will find ai form hetter adapted to the feeling of their nation than its own familiar patriarchal system; the immense antiquity of which can alone he explained by admitting its y to Chinese instincts. To not to deny system might, and must he, improved' in respect of details. Endless surveillance and the prac= tice of mutual responsibility which holds every man at charges' for the guilt of his brother, though practic able in the microcosm of a family or household, is too liable to. abuse, when applied to the extended life of the whole community, to he healthy basis for national udministration the principle of reduplicating autocracy, from the Emperor down to the smallest magistrate, opens the door to intolerable corruption and oppression. Tt is one of the standing paradoxes of the Chinese Empire that while it possesses a code of statutes, the foundations of which were laid turies azo, of remarkable simplicity, equity and directness. by which the Emperor himself is expected broadly to regulate his conduct of affairs, so much licence if not absolute illegalities should be tolerated at the hand of district officials; for whom the need of schools of training in the art of government is more apparent than for the unborn members of an
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.