The Archive · 1924

CHINESE WHITEWASH

"Vigace, and own Life ju China."

(George den B* Unwin} It is Wisappointing to find that a book of this kind, which is to be reenrded, one gathers from Professor Hobhouse's preface, as an interpretation of China to Europe, concentrates so closely on deseription of social institutions.

The preponderant importance of, the family in the Chinese scheme of things, the intricacies of ancestor the machinery of local govand so forth, are quite interesting, but they have been thoroughly reported in previous writings. A report is not an interpretation, and one expects something better when two gifted young.

who have taken "B.Sc down to ex-thir fellow-countrymen to us. Indeed, the reader who has wandered about in China speedily finds his interest concentrating on the psychology of the authors. Occasion ally the Asiatic ix frank to. a fellow—but never to a European. Always he dissimulates.

Nobody, one hazards, asked Mr. 'Tao, in his brief chapter on Town Life; to rake up such irrelevant. issues as occasional infanticide and wife-beating. But why, having raked them wp, hedge and' hum and haw, only to admit grudgingly that they do exist (though in the latter case, probably less commonly than in Britain)? Why say that "it may be true of the poorer classes: that the girl is never educated" when you know perfectly well that it is true?' Why make so misleading a statement as: "The ordinary [atmosphere of education itself Why tell British readers that "most complies Ss the caliany art China," when i is, sinplicty by comparison with the cookery of in Europe? So attomaticclly does the Asiatic whitewash" his fellow-country poople that it seems hopeless to expect 22 frank cards-on-the-table sort ook from an indigenous social interpreter cast of Roumania.

Hardly anything is told us in this book of the Teuctions of village of town Chinese to the world at large. How eagerly we should welcome another book in which the authors would report, with conscientious fcuraey, 2 large number of conversa~ tions with, and among, Chinese of fall social grades on the subject of the white man and his scheme of things, Incidentally it be a "world best sell day Westminster."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account