Judge Grain said:—As two brother Judges, Sir Skinner Turner and Sir Henry Gollan, have both upheld my original judgment, there is nothing further for me to say beyond concurring in their present judgments. But there are two sentence jin Sir Henry Gollan's judgment I should like to refer to.
He says:—"Mr. Justice Grai held that the Bank were not th agents of the defendants and therefore could not bind the defendants by any arrangement made with Grodetsky. I am inclined to the belief that this part of the learned Department do not agree parment Judge's judgment is open to question and that the Bank were the agents ofthe defendants for, the purpose of any operations falling within the credit opened in favour of Grodetsky." And Sir Honey the feet at we ships named. Ho! Gollan goes on to say:—"But. the yo maru 10—Hoyoimarg 11 and adv Hongkong @ Shanghs Banking Ce No danger of arrest faluntully, - Shengl 'A Guarantee And on the same date the dete dants wrote refusing to alter the terms of the letter of credit quested by Grodetsky. still continued between p defendants as to the course to be taken. Mr. Bos stated that the Bank wrote saying they had heard from their Vladivostok branch that shipment of the lumber would be permitted if the branch would guarantee Payment of dues to the Forest Dv. partment on telegraphic advice belt received from Shanghai that the ber had been Ianded there; that he saw Rodfeld of the plaintiff firm on the subject of this letter, that he (Bos) said the defendants would agree to the issue of the guarantee, and that Rodfeld seemed extremely pleased and said that the transaction would go through, (p. 33 of Judge's notes). Rodfeld does not agree with Bos's version of this interview, but, does admit that the subject of a guarantee was mentioned between them (pp. 17, 18, and 21 of Judge's notes).
In accordance with Mr. Bos' undertaking, the Vladivostok branch of the ' Bank,—by letter dated November ' 18, 1924, to Grodetsky, agreed to guarantee payment of amount due to Grodetsky after arrival of the timber at Shanghai, and Grodetsky on November 19 forwarded a copy of this letter to the Forest Department. The Forest duties of the Bank were limited to negotiating bills drawn by Grodctsky against full shipping documents—and the Vladivostok branch of the Bank had no power to agree to Pay export dues for which Grodetalone was responsible upon the Presentation merely of the bills of lading."
I will go further than Sir Henry] Goltan and say T consider that upon that point I was wrong. I have had some further cases called to wy attention which show me clearly that the Bank were agents of the defendants, but the point was not very material to my former decision, because had I found that the Bank were agents of the defendants I should have been compelled to find, as has been stated by Sir Henry Gollan, that the Viadivostok branch had no power to agree to pay the export dues for Grodetsky merely on the presentation of the bill of lading. In fact, although the Bank were agents, they exceeded their authority.
Having made these observations I have nothing further to add but to concur in the judgments of the other two members of this Court. Therefore this appeal is dismissed and the judgment of the Court below affirmed, with costs.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.