To the Editor of the "Nontn-Ciina Datty News."
Sw—I have read with interest Done's letter in your issue of May 9, With the change of one word let me apply to myself the last star ment in that letter. "My object in writing is only to endeavour to counteract the misleading impression that Done's letter is, liable to} Teave on the casual reader."
His reference to "a Prof, Wilson of Princeton Theological Seminary would give a casual reader the pression that Prof. Wilson obscure, unknown person, 50 as al preface' to my remarks it seems heeessary' to sive some facts along Prof, Robert Dick Wilton has} spent about 40 years studying the sages and literature bearing on the Old Testament. He has mastered Greek, Loti Hebrew, "Italian, Spanish, Port guese, Syriac, Arabic, the various leets, ' Babylonian, ninian,—Exyptie Coptic, Persian and "Armenian—all about 26 languages or dialects. Jhrader (called Assyriology). He! studied Arabic and Syriac under Sachau and Arabic under John and Dieterich, Hebrew under Dillman} and Strack and Egyptian under Brugsch.
After a patient and careful study in every language of all the extent literature having any bearing on. Old Testament criticism, Prof. son has come to the conclusion that the composite origin of the Penta-touch in the sense claimed by the critics ix a fallacy.
What, then, are we to do Done's" statement that "Biblical scholars are agreed that the Penta-touch ix a composite work ete"? The inference ix that Prof. Wilson not a Biblical scholar. In the! same way many other noted and brilliant contributors to the diseussion of Biblical questions would be ruled out.
Done has well illustrated the eriical position, which is practically this: "Those who agree with us are scholars; thos who disagree tus are not scholars."
There are many cogent reasons why conservative scholars refuse to accept the documentary hypothesis. Out of many passages that disprove that hypothesis let me refer briefly to two.
First, the critics claim that nowhere is the composite nature of the narrative more evident than in the Bible account of the deluge. But one of the Babylonian flood stories that zone back to about 2000
Bible narrative and contains. both the so-called J and E elements of that narrative. This startling. re-of the documentary moves Prof. Save logical mirage."
Secondly, take the narrative of the plagues. The first nine plagues, taken in the order given fall nu. turally into three in each series is by the words, "And the Lord said unto Moses, Rise up carly in the morning and stand before Pharaoh "To! he cometh forth to the water."
'The second plague in each series is introduced by "the words, "And the Lord said unto Moses, Go in' nto Pharaoh and say unto im: bro} Thus the first plague in each] series is announced to Pharaoh by the river side, and the second in his palace, but the third. in each series is: brought on without warning. This orderly arrangement could not be brought about by combining separate documents.
Compare with this analysis the one given in the Oxford Hexateuch. zo rho giver Waters t Water of feat net targed" toreea Fro Boils Death of Death of Death of Restborn first-born first-born Let the casual reader compare these two analyses and take his choice. As to the possibility of the Pentateuch having been written in the time of Moses (1300—1400 B.C), Prof. Save tells us that there' was a postal service between Canaan and Babylonia in the days of Naram Sin (about 2650 B.C.), and that some of the clay bullae Which served as stamps are now in the museum of" the Louvre. The Phoenician alphabet way invented several hundred years before the time of Moses," and the Hebrew Tanguage was spoken in Canaan before the time of the Exodus. There absolutely no reason why, the Pentateuch could not have been written in Hebrew by Moses, using either the Phoenician script or, the Babylonian cuneiform script, both'
jing current at that time, and Moss being "learned in all the wisdom of the Egyptians."
'The trouble with a great many' radical critics is that they are 0 wrapped up in their preconceiver theories that facts have no chance to penetrate. writer puts the matter]
Facts are quite helpless in the face of theories: For stter" all, most. facts When Wen Did saway's 0. "Dd you ever hea of 8 thenry cine contaved®™ T am, ete., Kuling, May 15, 1924,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.