The Archive · 1926

The Sole Controversy

"The gale controversy between the parties to the suit arose upon the question as to what kind of German marks the plainti® is entitled to receive in settlement df his claim—the plaintiff contending that they must be lawful marks' current in Germany on August 10, 1025 the date on which the policy was offered) for surrender, while the defendant launs that its obligation under the policy was fulfilled when it offered to deliver of 64,800 paper German marks, which were current and Iewful money of Germany when the policy was issued, "In the month of November, 1921, the plaintiff, then having on deposit the Sino-Italian Bank at Tientain to his credit 134,000.00 German marks, took out this policy of insurance paying as a premium there for the sum of 62,625.00 German marks, This policy ig what was commonly known and understood as 20-year paid up policy, insuring the life of the plaintiff in the sum of 100,000.00 German marks, and providing that after it had been in force for a period of three years, the insured should have the option to take and receive in cash, German marks according to the 'Table of 'Values' printed and inserted on the second page of the policy. At the time this policy was issued, to-wit, on November 14, 1921, these 62,525.00 German marks, which were paid as a premium, were worth at the then existing rate of exchange between Germany and the United States not to exceed 250 American Gold dollars. At the ime of the payment of the premium, the agents of the defendant returned. to the plaintiff the sum of 3,126.25 German marks as a commission on this self-same policy which the plaintiff deposited in his current marks account Deceber, 17, 1921, in the Sino-Italian Bank at Tientain, leaving a balance in that account of German marks 74,601.25, which has never Been withdrawn by the plaintiff from said bank, because the plaintiff regarded them as "valu Terms of the Policy "On November 14, 1924, this policy of insurance having been in force for of three years, the plainti entitled, according to its terms, 2 any time between that date and

his policy to the company and receive Rovemoer, 43985, to aurvender up In'leu thereof cash tothe amount of 54,800.00 German marks, and it is conceded that if plaintiff had elected {fo surrender up his said policy for cash at any time between" the November 14, and. June, 5, 1025, when the 'German law' took effect retiring from circulation these old German marks, that, the plaintiff' would have received from the Insurance Company 54,800.00 German marks of the kind and) character which he had paid to the company a3 premium in the pur-base of thi insurance policy, and that such German. marks, 54,800.00, would have been, at the then existing rate of exchange beween German marks and American fold currency, of a lose value than One-seven hundredth part of one ent of American "currency. The! evidence shows, and I think it conceded by counsel for the plain-if, that for more than one year prior "to June 5, 1925, when the German Government, by its fiat, abolished from its cireultion the old-paper mark, which up to that time had been legal tender in Germany for more than 10 years, the paper mark was the equivalent, fin value of one-billionth part of an English shilling. On June 5, 1925, a law of Germany went into' effect, establishing what was be known thereafter as the gold mark, a3 the unit of value and Tegal tender Sri, Germany, and same time this law declared that the old paper mark' should Tonger be considered as legal tender jin Germany.

"Within 65 days after this law in Germany. became operative, demonetizing the old German paper marks @s legal tender of the country, to-wit, on August 10, 1925, the plaintiff in this action through his counsel, wrote a letter to the defendant at its Shanghai office, informing the defendant that plaintiff intended to take advantage of Option No, 4 of Clause 14 of plaintiffs insurance policy, and that hho intended to surrender up said insurance policy to the defendant. with the consent of the beneficiary, Jeanne H, Oliver, and take in liew thereof the cash surrender value of said policy, which was fixed at 54,- £800.00 German marks. The defendant was advised in that letter that. the necessary forms to be executed in connexion with the surrender of said policy, together with the consent of the beneficiary, would be prepared, and that they, together with the policy would be forwarded fe the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation at Shanghai with instructions to deliver and surrender the same to the defendant "in exchange for a sight draft on Berlin for German marks 54,800.00 drawn in favour of the insured.' On August 14, the Insurance Company advised ' the defendant that there was no occasion for taking the matter up with the Hongkong and Shanghai Bank, in view of the fact that defendant had ite own offices in Peking, and advising the plaintiff that the defendant was forwarding to its Peking office the necessary receipt for Mr. Oliver to sign, and a draft drawn by the Deutsche Asiatische Bank of Hankow on the Deutsche Asiatische Bank of Berlin on August, 3, 1923, {for 62,575.00 marks made payable "It was explained in this letter that the draft was in excess of the amount which Mr. Oliver's policy called for, namely 54,800.00 marke, but that inasmuch as the value of German marks had so much depreciated, they did not think it} worth while to ask Mr. Oliver to return to the Insurance Company} the difference. Thereafter, on August 19, 1925, plaintiff replied in a letter that the offer of the letter of August was not acceptable, for the reason that it did not conform with the terms of the policy, or meet the requirements of the law, and further] stating that what' the insured required in settlement of said polic; was a draft on Germany drawn in favour of the insured in the sum of marks 54,800.00

The Conclusion Continuing, the ruling contains. an elaborate analysis of the transaction and presents many other} cages that were quoted in the course fof the hearing. The ruling concludes as, follows:

"If this contract had been made in Germany in precisely the same manner in which it was made in China and the plaintiff were now] seeking to enforce this contract in Germany, the defendant would be required to pay nothing, or practically nothing. I cannot believe that! 'a citizen of the United States, doing business either in China' or should be required to settle jons with respect to the old German currency in terms of the new German gold currency recent-

"T therefore hold as conclusions of law that the defendant has performed, or has offered to perform, its contract under this policy when'

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account