To these words of commendation must be added one serious criticism, It is to be regretted that so nee is given to the poli lation, the discussion of treaty rights, extraterritoriality and kind red questions. The first 70 and the Nast 50 pages of the book are taken tup with such matters, more than name, and nearly two coloured plates and over 60 other Much of this is propaganda with have become familiar with the The intention, no doubt, is to years since the strviving son of itustrations. The editors have out- very little basis of trath in it, but comparatively small vocabulary of present the "Christian" view of the Mancha Dynasty left the For-one themselves and have spared it is none the less read and beliewvituperation which is used over and these problems, but the impression hidden City for a Foreign Conces-pains to make it a volume of, ed, and has been an important factor over, Simil ly, the contents conveyed is of special pleading sion. Peking has fallen from its extraotiinary interest and" at-{in' the evolution of the present the volume are' somewhat less in-Jealeulated to support Chinese nae high estate, and in no direction is trnctiveness, and it will find a warm'situation. The foreigner is hand! che change more perceptible than in teresting than the earlier ones, for tionalist propaganda, there is much repetition of what the decay of tis palaces and altars.
We notice especially that in these is getting to be an old story.
It Jdiscussions of the—tres Many since Marco Polo have nevertheless contains a great deal writers are silent or evi described its streets "so wide and of material which is of value in on straight that you can see right along Htracing the development of the dangerous shorn from one gate to another ation, and which could - not need for treaty rev out few have had the opportunity jclsewhere be found collected in one|sion and readjustment of the condi.
studying the Imperial Palaces in the Forbidden City, and probably volume. tions under which foreigners—live Some @5 pages are devoted tol and work in China (on that there none of photographing them under diary of events, political,|is, we believe, no real difference if the personal guidance of the military, and public "movements,|opinion) can' the existing treaties emperor. To Professor Siren ea covering from August 1924 to April be abandoned unconditionally and he opportunity during his stay in This is of great convenience Peking in 1922, and he has fully for reference immediately? When individually in locating various profited by it.' The result is an pressed with this specific question happenings, and will save scarchwe have found that those who outstanding example of the photo-Jing through newspaper files, The dently champion China's "right rapher's and printer's art, and remaining 210 pages are taken up acknowledge that the desired contains 274 collotypes, 12 drawings with 150 selections, arranged this changes must be gradual and condi-and two maps, in addition to 70 time chronologically, without any tional. Yet we have not soon or mages of text.' Its format is royal classify tion by subject.
These heard this made plain in their iptive matter speeches of Karakhan and]
elegant French face on toned Dublic writings, utterances, or Sun Yat-sen, communist _program-solutions. By this omission we be-printing paper, and the collotypes mes, accounts of student strikes, lieve a distinct disservice hay been exquisitely produced, each picture the May 30 affair, and various de-separately attached to a linen stub clarations on it by Chinese and] to the Chinese Christian community rendered to China, and particularly The first volume has just been foreign bodies, and other topies of|which has sorely needed guidance. ued by the publisher and will be welcome. As a matter of fact, the capped in getting this material by year. [To have joined in the popular de-allowed by two others to complet: coloured plates included in this language difficulties, whether total! The volume, like the preceding] nunciation of existing treaties, and he worl issue are in themselves worth more, or partia}, the variety oer of the series, is indispensable] professed readiness to abandon The photographs which Profcsthan the cost of the magazine. of the mediums in which it is pud-|*® the foreigner who wishes to have|them, without indicating what are or Siren set out to take are not There are reproductions of two lished, so that the average foreign a record of the occurrences and the necessary conditions and pre-rare architectural documents, but water colour studies by Elizabeth ex would not have the time te) the the atmosphere of recent years in paratory steps, it not to have helped cave been taken to present' the Otis Dunn of Shanghai, who is now read them, even if his China, towards good understanding,—but laces in their natural setting of, the foremost interpreter of Chinese knowledge' of Chinese were ex-to have seriously hindered it,' More. rees and gardens, and to give an child life, and two reproductions of cctlont. Occasional translations are lover, we believe that by this parti pression of the beauty of nature oil paintings by Mary A. Mullikin,' published in the foreign press in
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.