May 26.
Anour the year 60 of our era, there was a celebrated trial in the city of Cwsarea in Palestine, On that occasion the prosecuting attorney said to Herod Agrippa, the judge, that the case did not hang on any of the usual legal charges but was a dispute between the Jewish rulers, who that a certain famous teacher of their nation was dead, whereas the prisoner, Paul, asserted that he was alive, It was a peculiar point to occupy the attention of a Roman court.
A detailed and very interesting account of the trial is given in book too well known to require to be named, and the position is yet so far unsettled that a very serious division arisen in some of the larger denominational—church in America over this very question one party, the—Modernists, maintaining the views of the Jewish leaders of 2,000 years ago, that the person referred to is really dead, and the other, the Fundamentalists, insisting that he is alive. Lawyers could quote many causes célébres in which the question whether a certain party to the suit was alive or not was debated some of the brightest lights of the legal profession, There was the Tichbourne case which came for trial in 1868. The eldest son of Sir James Francis Tichbourne was lost at sea in a vessel called the Bella which sailed from Rio de Janeiro. in 1854, His mother, as mothers will, refused to believe the report of her son's death. She advertised for him in many papers and ultimately received a reply from a butcher in the town of Wagga-wagga in Australia, The claimant was as unlike the lost son as could possibly be imagined. The son was a slim youth with straight black hair and could speak English only with a French accent. 'The claimant was' a stout man with fair wavy hair, knew no French and spoke very rude English, In spite of these, and many other proofs to the contrary, Lady Tichbourne be-Hieved that this was her pro-dial; she took him to her heart and loved and trusted him till the day of her death. More astonishing still, scores of people identified the claimant as the heir and huge sums of money were subscribed to enable him to substantiate his claim. Tt was a case of the Englishman's love of justice for the under dog running to seed, but a hard-hearted judge and jury convicted the claimant of perjury and sent him to prison for fourteen years. Then, on the other side, there is the tale of Enoch Arden, who was really alive but returned to his home to find that he was legally dead and, finding that there was no niche for him in a world that was dead to him, decided to remain dead to the world but, by a.whimsical turn of fate, was immortalized by Tennyson, These instances show that it is not an easy problem to decide whether a man is alive or dead.
We have the case of Dr. Sun occupying the attention of the world.and, at the present moment, he would be a bold man who would predicate the truth or falsity of the rumours that have-reached us of his decease.
It may be said that Dr. Sun }has merely to saunter out of his office, if he be really alive, and show himself to. any one of a dozen reporters who are "des-berately anxious to get authentic copy and utterly indifferent whether he is "to be or not be" as long as they can be certain whether they ought to use a negative or affirmative in making their report. But what would story-tellers and writers of fiction do for a living if every good plot were settled in this ff-hand, matter-of-fact fashion? Reuter's correspondent at Canton, Mr. Hin Wong, ventured to report that it rumoured Dr. Sun was dead and he is now in prison, doubtless meditating on the blessing of living under a constitutional Republican government. Later Mr. C. M, MeDonald went as a special correspondent to Canton and said, in effect, to Mr. Eugene' Chen, Dr. Sun's secretary, "Bring out your lion and let him roar for me and I'll soon put an end to all this pother.". Mr. Chen was indignant to the point of discourtesy and pointed out that it is open to any man at any time to assert that any other man is dead. And if we are all Viable to be called on, every now and then, to prove that we are not dead—and we have shown at the beginning of this article, what a difficult task that is why! what is to become of us? We have some sympathy with Mr. Chen.
Editors, as well as politicians, find it necessary to be "not at home" to callers sometimes and y|we are at all times too busy to take time to demonstrate our aliveness to those who presume to doubt it. At the same time Dr, Sun—presuming he is alive—and Mr. Eugene Chen are re-/viving the methods of the tyrants of barbarous days when they throw a man into prison and threaten his life for presuming to whisper that the King is dead. A drastic action of this kind makes what may be an idle rumour look very much a3 though it might be true. And true or false it is a wrong thing to do anyway. It is recorded that in the battle of Hastings 4 rumour spread that Duke William was dead. The Norman leader at once removed his helmet, rode out in front of the ranks and so reassured his men. Later it was said that King Harold was slain and as the rumour was true the English King could not imitate his opponent; therefore the battle was lost and Duke William became King of England. We commend the story to Dr. Sun's attention.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.