The Archive · 1908

Smoking in Hongkong

1 have now drawn attention to what I believe to be some of the false premises upon which Mr. Clementi has: based his calculatio"is. Let' me now pass op to that portion of his Report which relates to opiam smoking in Hongkong. It will be noted that ax regards the population of the Colony. which includes the New Territories at Kowloon on the mainland, he states that "the figures for ritories are not available hare been under British control for a number of years! He goes on to calenlate the percentages in Hongkong and rives at the conclusion that the ratio is 12.942 per cent of the entire adult population.

It will be noted at once that while he oes to a considerable amount of trouble in an endeavour to prove that the ratio in China Proper is. at most only two per cent of the entire population, his figures for Hon kong (where, as he says "we no longer deal with estimates boat with accurate figures) indicate that the percentage is ax high ax 12.942 per cent, while the Opium Farmer he telts us puts it at ten per cent. 1s it cerolible that the percentage of smokers in Hongkong is in fact wuch jsreater than in Chinx Proper Is it likely that the incentive to smokeopian is much greater in Hongkong than in (hina, where the drag is Mr. Clementi pats the average dose ce. If, ax is probable, the average se ix 1 mace then the ratio of smokers in Hongkong is about 25 per cent.

If the percentage of smokers is in fact so much greater in Hongkong than in China then it woald seem to stand to reason—if weare really, as Sic E. Gray and other statesmen have indicated, desirous to help China—that no time should be lost in suppressing the traffic of His Majesty's ions.

Under the heading plication of smoke prepared opium in divans are also slaves of the habit also after the abolition of divans the Opiam Farmer will continue, as heretofore, to possess the right of selling prepared opium and dross opium to the general public."

Here, then, we find Mr. Clementi going so far sx actually to premise that many people addicted to the opium habit are enslaved by it. He is right smokers gradually become enslayed by the habit.

The Chinese censas—npon which Mr. Clementi bases his figures is wholly unreliable. In taking the census in China, District Officials are supposed to count the number of houses and report the total—which may or may not be correct—to their chiefs, the Governors or Viceroys of Provinces, As far as Lam aware the population of the Empire is calculated by estimating five human beings to each house, This is of course a very loose way of doing it, and it is, therefore, particularly noteworthy that Mr. Clementi has referred to the census of Chien ina manner calculated to lead the general public to suppose that it is taken in much the same way as estimates of population are computed in western States, He offers no explanation, enlightenment on the subject, Although Mr. Clementi attacks Mr. Theodore Taylor, att for saying "the blackest' spots are unter British rule" yet his figures far to prove that Mr. Taylor spoke the truth, there being (a he alleges) only 1 per cent of amokers in China but 12 per cent in Hongkong. The folly, or rather the madness, of any attempt on the part of Great Britain prevent the Chinese Government fro giving fall effect to the Anti-Opiam edicts will be realized by those who are acquainted with the despotic aystem of Government in China, Whether we had seen fit to adopt a sympathetic policy or otherwise, the Chinese Government would of course continue the a against opium, and when it considered the time for very drastic measures had arrived would issue orders to all Viceruys, Governors and District Magistrates that on and alter a certain date all persons, of whateever rank or station in life, who are fonnd continuing the evil habit of opium ing must be summarily decapitated in public ax n warning t" others. Thus, although the right to import Tovtian Opin continued despite hina' appeal for help, the trade in it would be ultimately extinguished and we would have lost a golden opportunity to act up to our precepts and insure to ourselves and to our successors a mensure of power and prestige and commercial prosperity in the Far Orient sach as other nation will ever have an opportunity to acquire. The Gorernment of the day has noted wisely, and I believe it to be a matter of paramount import ance that it should be demonstrated here in Shanghai and in Hongkong and the Strait in no uncertain manner, that Great Britain ix determined to do all that lies in her power to assist China to efface as rapidly ne possible from these regions the Inst vestige of a habit which makes for the degradation of all who are addicted to it. We should close all the divans, we should establish Opium Refuges, give habitual smokers a few—months' grace in which to give up smoking, and encourage the Chinese to establish Anti-Opiam Sucieties in their cities, the snbarbs, and all the villages under their control by setting the example in those under oar control.

Owing to the impossibility of obtaining accurate returns of the production and movements of native opium, also owing to the unreliability x Unig inal from

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account