The following letter appears in The Times" from its Shanghai correspondent "THe Times." to Mr. Taylor's "of April, under the heading of Anti-Opium Movement in China," in which he criticizes an article of imine on the same subject, of April 4, T trast you will permit me to draw your attention to certain in his statement, errors whi rected, are calculated further to mis lead the British public on a subject mberein sound judgement is being grievously sacrificed to sentiment.
While applauding the genuineness of the determination of China's Government to stamp out this great curse," he observes that the Empire is "a inese federation of semi-independent provincial Governments," implying, 1 presume, that from such " body-politi- too much must not be expected; and finally, lo says that the results up to now are simply marvellous." In one I concurin this conclusion; the results of the Chinese Government's policy are simply marvellous in England and other countries where ill-balanced sentiment often outweighs the teachings of history and political science; but, when he quotes the best observers on the spot, such as Sir John Jordan, Sir Robert Hart, and the Peking Correspondent of The Times" as sharing his opinion as to marvellous results in only say that the wish must father to the statement, for not one of the three gentlemen to whom he refers holds, or has held, this opinion. The are, as we all are, entirely sympathy assured also of the genuine national poise at the back of the movement, and the strength of public opinion; but they suspend judgement, as all but enthusiasts must do, in deciding as to the genuineness and effect of the Governwent's attitude and actions.
On the other the question, the side which the curiously optimist attitude of modern homanitaria declines to consider, let me actual words of an English mi doctor, an observer far more than any gatherer of fac opinions in Peking. Dr. Main, of the Church Missionary Hospital at Hangchow says For more than a quarter of a century' we have made consistent protest against the habit, and have held out " helping hand to those who were anxious to be cured of the vice. A few weeks before the closing of the dens we had more applicants for admission to the refuge than we could receive. At one time we had.as many as fifty-five. Sincetheclosing of the dens, anti-opium pills, containi morphia or opium in some fornr, been freely distributed by the gent and shops for the sale of these an! opium pills are opened everywhere and doing a roaring trade. Onur refuge has been empty for months, and in fact we have now no use for it, Orig Some have been cured, but most of those who frequented the opium de have simply replaced the pipe by mor. phia pills, and the last state is. wor than the first. The Government hms yet a big job before it, and the end in view may be best attained through the recent agreement between England in China, which provides for a poral reduction of the growth of opium in Ching and the importation of the drug from India, and the strict prohibition of morphia into the country. The former obligation is a most important one and will have to be very carefully watched, and unless the officials exert themselves in a very different way in the future from what they have done in the past, we "hae our doors" as the results being satisfactory. There is no love lost between the officials ani the people: the chief aim of most officials. is to grind like a soulles machine as much money as they can, and that ax quickly as possible, out vi the people. The greed of gain is the rock on many of them split, There are a few exceptions to this rul, and we meet occasionally officials why really care for the tu of the people, and who find in doing so thy are advancing the interests of their country.
Tu conclusion, let me refer to the fina paragraphs of Mr. Taylor's letter, which contain a remarkable misstate ment of my criticism of Japan's action in the matter of this opium question If he will read my article again he will see that I did not refer to the Japanese Government's "indifference in Korea" nor to her action in any territory under her own protection or control. What I did say, and maintain, ix that if England is supporting the Chine Government in abolishing opium-suicking in Chinese territory, ite attitude would gain in fore and effect if supported by our Japanese allies," and I pointed out that in which is Chinese territory, the Japanese authorities are openly encouraging the opium traffic, Unjustifiably substitu: for Manchuria, Mr. the conclusion that we ize Japan's action because of the policy adopted by British colonies in the Enst—eg., Hongkong and the Straits Settlement—In dealing with the opium question, If this argument means hing it means that he condones Japan's arbitrary die regard of the opium edicts in Chins because certain British colonies have led to apply experience and common sense, rather than impetuous sentimentality, to this important question. Apart from the financial results of the abolition of licensed opium-smoking, which must involve a complete resd-justment of taxation, ete., in thee colonies, and, therefore, demand reasonable period of transition, it is evident to the trained. experience and intelligence of administrators on the spot that, until the Chinese Government have given satisfactory proof of their honest intention to suppress (gradually) the cultivation of opiam. any drastic regulations rendering its consumption illegal would not only be
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.