Shanghai, August 10, re A. Bourne Esq., Judge. owners of the 8. 8. B:
Mr. N.C. Home appeared for the plaintiffs and Mr. R, N. Macleod for the defendants.
Mr. Home said that this was the plaintiffs' motion for special leave to appeal against the judgement in this case which was rendered in favour the defendants. The application was made under the Order in Council section 115, subsection 5, by which the Court had power even in cases where the amount involved was less than £500, to give special leave to appeal. Counsel submitted that this was such a case. The amount actually involved was $1,000, but that was no indication whatever of the importance of the case. The particular amount was more or less accidental; it was a question of the interpretation of certain exceptions set forth in a bill of lading which was adopted in s common form by the members of the shipping hongs and to' which practically all shippers to Shanghai to submit. importance and counsel submitted that it was s case in which the plaintiffs should be allowed' to appeal. There was no issue of fact whatever: it was simply "question of In Mr. Macleod submitted that this was a case where leave to appeal should not be granted. The defendants had no desire to prevent the plaintiffs in this case, or in any other case, from getting a decision of the highest Court possible, but counsel argued that there was nothing to be gained by the plaintiffs or the class to which the plaintiffs belonged in Shanghai, by thi: appeal. If the plaintiffs were allowed to appeal in this case it would probably cost them ax much as they would get from the defendants for the damage done to the cargo. There would probably be such " small balance that looking at it from this point of this case only it could not be said that there was any advantage to the plaintiffs in allowing them to appeal.
His Lordship said that the plaintiffs must judge of that for themselves.
Mr. Macleod asked his Lordship to hear him on the question of whether anything was to be gained by appeal. It really did not make much difference to the plaintiffs monetarily, whether they won the appeal or not.
His Lordship said that what he wanted to hear from Mr. Macleod was whether the appeal was vexatious or not. It was a very important matter and unless counsel could show that the plaintiff was asking for leave to appeal altogether from s wrong motive and not because he wanted to get the law wattled, but because be either wanted delay or was acting in " vexatious manner, his Lordship ought to give His Lordship did not' Macleod could say that there was any injustice to his clients in granting this application for Mr. Home said that plai paid defendants' costs already.
Mr. Macleod replied that when the case was small the amount of costs received was small. The point was that it was not fair to pat the defendants, who had won their case here, to a ut of costs equal to that which aintiffs would gain if they won, supposing the case was for $100, his Lordship would searcely grant leave to appeal unless it was shown that some important principle or point of law was involved. Counsel proposed to show was not so in thi case and that the appeal would put th defendants to an expense which would bring about no result whatever. The whole point in this case was a matter of the constraction of " particular clause in w particular document. It was a very small point. It was argued by Mr. Home that there was an ambiguity, but the learned Assistant indge argued that there was no ambiguity. In dealing with the case the learned Assistant Judge said with Bs very contention raised by the hat the contention or the reading which the plaintiff wished to pot on the wording of this clause was not the proper one. There was no wide principle of law involved it was simply question whether certain words in thie contract were) ambiguous, Mr. Home's contention was that if this decision was upheld, then all consignees having coming to Shanghai hed no redress whatever. If that were true it would bea very important matter, but it was not so. This was a question of contract. A shipper should not accept bill of lading which he considered unfair. If he did accept it how could he complain afterwards? Consi usually bought goods on a bill of lading: should they buy goods on a Lill of lading which they considered His Lordship said that the consignees had nothing to say on the question of the bill of lading. The point made in the newspaper criticisms was that they bad to ship by certain lines which were able to impose the terms they chose.
Mr. Macleod said that if that were s0, consignees would go to the shipers and say that they would not ship on these terms. It was " matter of negotiation between the two parties. There was also the farther remedy of the shipper at home and that was that he could insure.
His Lordship said that all this the plaintiff had had to consider for bim-self. The plait said that the defendants were liable and the Jadge found that they were not liable and the plaintiff enid that he would like the jadgement of the highest Court on it. counsel could show that the plaintiffs' desire to appeal was frivolous or vexations his Lordship would much prefer, and the learned Assistant Judge this decision would prefer, that hould get the jadgement Mr. Macleod said that it was intended clearly by the Order in Council where " small amount was at stake that the appeal be allowed only where there was an important principle at stake.
His Lordship said that his point of view was this: That the learned Assistant Judge heard case carefully and he read a very long and" carefal judgement and nalesshe had thought that, there was something in the case, he would not have taken the trouble, to write out a long judgement. Unless 'a Jadge had to explain his reasons for the public to know, he did not write out along judgement. The learned Assistant Judge was not here to hear this opplication himself and his Lordship reasoned from the fact that Mr. Justice Vincent wrote out a judgement and gave his reasons at such length, that he did think that there was " difficalt point.
Mr. Macleod said they were told that it was important becanne it affected the mercantile commanity of Shanghai and counsel wanted to show his Lordship that it did not and could not affect the mercantile community to great extent.
His Lordship said that counsel could not prove that. It seemed to his Lordship that they did not know which way to cover—insurance risk or shipping risk. If the judgement was sound they had to insure against that risk. It was very hard for counsel to show that it did not interest the mercantile community. The mercantile community
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.