The Archive · 1924

Parallel Cases

'What is the evidence here? Apart from an alleged confession of adult tery, it is to the effect that the wite was violent tempered, and at Gates in 1922 had abused, threatened, and even struck her' husband: the instances given being at long intervals apart, and there being no instance between, December 1922 and September 1923. I cannot say that such conduct "is enough to justify the husband in leaving his wife, and Tam following here the Gecisions of two such experienc: Judges in these cases as the late Sir Samuel Evans and Mr. Justice Shearman. I take the later case of the two, Greene v. Greene, already mentioned, tried by. Mr. Fustice Shearman. The evidence was to the following effect: "The petitioner was hysterical and jean Tous. She made false accusations against her husband and wrote affectionate letters to other men: she had written letters which no modest sensible woman would have written, but it is not suggested that there was any guilty intimacy between her and the recipient. She was furiously jealous of her hus band, with the not unnatural result of her outbursts that after a time he separated himself from her more and more, with the further result that, if the husband's evidence be accented, she gradually gave way to drink. Then we find. the usual concomitants—untrue tions and hysterical outburst judge, notwithstanding this. evid-fence, and without calling upon the wife to answer it, felt that he would be extending the law if he held that the husband in this case had rea~ sonable ensue for deserting his wite and granted her a decree of restitution. This was on the same principles as led Sir $. Evans to grant 'a decree to another wife—Fletche:

Fletcher (1915)—where that the conduct of the wil justify the husband in withdrawing his protection from her: protection which included not only providing for het livelihood but giving-her his society, his care, and that anchorage in life which a frivolous and foolish woman required." am satisfied on the principles evolve them from the authorities that, oven were I to accept the respondent's evidence, he has not (apart from the alleged confession) shown mo reasonable cause the. same time I hold that he has failed to prove the charges he has made against her.

The Alleged Misconduct I come now to the alleged confession of adultery, said to have been made by the wife in September 1922." This, if proved and true, would be enough to lead me to refuse the prayer of the petitioner. Again, there is no evidence before me save the word of the part and the surrounding circumstance It is suggested that this woman, the mother of two small children, ame back from her summer holiday and rather boasted of her intimacy with several men at Tsingtao during that holiday. She strenuously. denies the fact and the confession. 'Why should she make such a con: fession? 'The parties, even if their relations were strained, were living, under the same roof: why present her husband with this evidence, if true? And the more so, if untrue' And why did not the husband take steps to ascertain more, or even to Team where he was with such a his hands? He of the sort, and the parties continued to live under the same roof, Nay, more; in 1923 he sends his wife with both the children! at his expense to the same place for the summer; and it is only while they are there that he writes the letter of August 17 definitely refusing to live any longer with the wife. In no single letter is any reference made to this confess sion: it fs clear to me that he paid no real attention to it and did not believe it, even if made. Why should And'T cannot believe that the wife ever made such a confession. I have referred to this matter in this way because it would be most unsatisfactory if I were merely to: say that the respondent had failed to prove it. There is no reasonable cause here for the desertion of the wife.

The prayer of the petitioner must be granted: there will be an order for restitution of conjugal. rights te be obeyed in 14 days after service, with costs.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account