Counsel's Argument: Flowers of Oratory in the Dry Land' of Legal Defence The final arguments in the ease Drought by Br. Herbert Webb against the "China Press" for damages for breach of contract, occupied the whole day on Monday, in the United States Court for China, before Judge. Purdy. The Court was again filled with people, interested spectators of a most interesting case.
Mr. Rodger reminded the Judge that the defendants pleaded an affirmative defence to the claim, ind it was for them, therefore, to prove that defence. They had made Uhree allegations against Mr. Webb; that he had failed to perform his duties under the contract; that he failed to obey the lawful and rea sonable orders of the Board of Directors; and that by the use of intoxicating liquors he had unfitted and incapacitated himself, both physically and mentally, for the proper discharge of his duties. Thes then, were the only issues before the Court The Order as to Hours Take first, that charge that had failed to discharge his duties under the contract. (Phe defence pleaded that he had failed to the lawful instructions of th tors. In the whole 13 years that Webb had been in charge of the paper he had only once been given instructions by the directors at all, and that was seven days before his dismissal, when he had been ordered to adopt the working hours of 9-12 and 2-5, Counsel submitted that not only was the order un-Feasonable, but it was not even given in good faith. They had had the testimony of " number of witness all experienced newspaper men and women, who had unanimously told the Court that such hours were absurd and impossible for the editor of a morning paper. Such an ore der, if carried out, would have prevented Mr, Webb from fulfilling that part of his contract which gave him complete control and a com mission on ndvertisomonts and sale How could he have exercised proper control if he was not on the premises Inst at night when the put to bed." The rea-the order was not given ith was that it was given Webb's contract.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.