Things being as they are, one question at once assails us: On such foundation of malarial body and fatalistic mind can India ever hope to build up democracy and industrialism? "Lord Ronaldshay is up, obviously doubtful. Our incorrigible confidence in the superiority of our the own. political nostrums is, he hints, the only driving power behind our gift of the elective principle; whatever politicians may pretend, it has awakened no answering chord in India's secret ambitions. Similarly, he fears that the organization of power industries on a large scale is alien to the genius of the Indian heart. is not machinery alongside of which he toils;" and he is consequently doom. ed to inefficiency. If we are wrong in pressing representative institutions and industrial development on India, Lord Ronaldshay does not suggest alternatives.. Perhaps they are reserved for the following volume which he promises, and to which we shall look forward with keen anticipation, Behind the climate and psychology and the play of temperament, there stand two of India's gravest practical issues—her racial problem and her North-West frontier. It is the fashion to belittle sometimes convenient to forget the other; but they are both stark realities. How deep and fundamental are the differences between Hindu and Moslem is made abundantly clear by Lord Ronald-and in five instructive chap-traces the history and the increasing magnitude of the frontier question. Our first punitive expedition in Waziristan was with a force of 1,500 men: our latest required an army of 80,000. The Tirah cameign cost £124,000; the operations of 1919-20 cost £16,000,000. some ways this is the most striking part of the book. It warns us that, whatever place we may allow for sentiment in the great political experiment which is proceeding in India to-day, we must keep a reserve of unfettered power to prevent the whole structure from dissolving in violence.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.