The Archive · 1920

Religion or Nationality

To the Editor of the "Norta-Cama Dairy News."

Sim,—I am much obliged to your correspondent "E. L. K." for giving me the welcome news that Prozessor Albert Kinstein is looked upon as being a Jew. 1 hope that the worthy Doctor admits it, though personally 1 think that he is of that race or religious sect which is constantly brutalized, derided and exploited by unscrupulous millions of people who are not related to Jews. My strong inclination to think him a Jew is owing (1) to the similarity of his new philosophy or rather method of philosophical reasoning on abstract matters which I. have not had an opportunity of studying (and as I believe that he treats mostly on astronomy, which is a blank to my intelligence, 1 fear I cannot hope to consciously quote him as my authority). (2) and a Jewish morning prayer call "Boraitha d'Rabbi Ismael" which contains 13 points of cause and effect in committing sin or doing good; but these 13 points are useful to the scientist or the man of understanding for erudite and close reasoning so that the chapter on the Roman law of "Onduca" may be entirely climinated. I mention here Point 6 which might assist me in maintaining my coming statement:

"Pwo general propositions, separated from each other by an enumeration of particulars, include only such things as are similar to those specified."

In view of the wel! known fact that religious persecution and ill-will does exist amongst many classes of non-Jews against the Jew of any title or denomination, one cannot help seeing the slur sticking out on a criminal brought before.a Russian Consular Court (not before the Mixed Court as stated by "E. DI, K.") when mentioning his double attributes as a means of recognition or identity, whilst a Roman Catholic, Pro: testant or Mohammedan appearing at a judicial court is not marked with the religious qualification, when not necessary, as was done by your reporter in the case of a man named Rosenberg, without copying the dossary or interrogatory in the law case mentioned.

As to the lan of Relativity, or in this humble case "Cause and Effect," the Jews of Shanghai may well afford to admit that amongst so many evil-doers in this port, there appears an occasional Jew. There are so many Jews of probity and worth in Shanghai that a reporter may hesitate at times to proclaim an evil-doer as 'a Jew if he happens to be one.

As yet, there is no Jewish Consul in Shanghai, but the Jewish interest represented on the Council is for religious purposes alone on account of the Jewish school where children of many nationalities are taught.the Jewish religion and

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account