The Archive · 1908

MORAL EDUCATION

August 17, Toe was when a young man prior to receiving a commission in the army might be asked, by way of examination, bow he spelt sword and if he answered s-o-r-d- his examiner would probably reply: " Well, well, we generally omit the © and insert a w. Thank you, that will do very nicely." To-day a great deal more is expected from our young men, for whatever profession they desire to qualify. Education, indeed, is now taken very seriously, for it has into the foreground of domestic politics, having become at once the war-cry of parties, the hobby of cranks and the obsession of specialists. In spite, however, of the unanimity with which its importance is emphasized, no general agreement exists regarding the natare and purpose of education. The most popular view at the present moment—fortunately not always among those who actually teach and for this reason say least in the matter, but among those who send their children to be taugbt—is that education should fit boy to fill the position for which his parents have destined him. Education, that is to say, should be directly utilitarian and immediately helpful in enabling a boy to become wage-earner. To this view is due the intermittent outery against the classics and the growing disfavour with which their study is regarded, as well as that of any subject which has no direct connexion with the earning of pounds, shillings and pence. The standard of revolt,. however, against this essentially materialistic doctrine has now been raised by a band of enthusiasts who preach utilitarian education of a totali; different character. Next mon' an International Moral Education Congress is to be held in London, and in the July number of " The Fortnightly Review" its objects are set forth earnestly" and somewhat quaintly, but, it is to be feared, not altogether conclusively. The Congress meets to inaugurate a movement which aims at making morality almost the Alpha and Omega of education. Lady Grove, the writer of the article, is able to muster a formidable list of patrons to prove that this new form of utilitarianism enjoys the widest, favour, bat no very clear conception is conveyed of the precise method to be adopted tw give practical effect to the doctrine.

With a detailed report of the deliberations of the Congress we may expect to obtain a fuller understanding of its proposed modus operandi, and in the meantime we may content ourselves with the foreword of its protagonist. At the outset it must be said that in the abstract the movement has everything in its favour. The aim of the pioneers of moral education, we are told, ito permeate every subject and every single lesson with the moral idea. No difficulty is experienced in grasping this purpose in regard to history, geography, literature and composi we can also see our way to extending it to classics, modern languages and nataral science; but we must confess that the application of this all-pervading moral atmosphere to mathematics warrants a misgiving lest excess of enthusiasm should spoil a good cause, Lady Grove, however, will have none of it. "Truthfulness is inexorably interwoven with arithmetical accuracy," and we instinctively remember that George Washington's education, though sadly elementary and defective in other respects, was sound in mathematics in which for the most part he was self-taught.

Clearly everything that makes for the development of the human race on moral lines deserves the strongest support of all thinking people, and it is to be hoped that the claim put forward that the moral education movement is no Utopian scheme, but "is intensely practical" will in due course receive actual demonstration. Foremost among its stampling-blocks must be reckoned the existing educational machinery, upon which it must depend for its application. So long as the scholastic profession hus to rely for its recruits upon those who find themselves with no special bent in life or otherwise out of employment, education must to a large extent be perfunctory, unsatisfactory. The real schoolmaster, who is born, not made, knows by his own experience the trath of the theory propounded in Lady Grove's article, that coercive methods to maintain the necessary discipline are not necessary in schools where the education is conducted on true pedagogical lines. And yet how many schools or classes are to be met with where there is no call for coercive measures Where they are to he found "moral education" may hit upon a favourable soil; but it requires an incorrigible optimism to consider them sufficiently numerous to exercise an appreciable influence on the immediate development of the race.

Although many will not share the roseate expectations of the pioneers of the moral education movement, any step, however isolated, in the direction of checking the unmor.l tendencies of the day will be widely welcomed. The precise degree of relationship existing between literature and crime will never be established, in spite of the many attempts that have been made to determine it. But we may accept the dictum that, while literature, in so far as it presents crime as crime, is comparatively innocuous, when it presents crime as duty, self-realization or aesthetic gratification, it becomes dangerous. By this test the recent development in contemporary litera ture that relies upon the realism with which the mirror is held up to the baser aspects of nature must stand condemned, From the phase of wsthetic contemplation it has passed to s proselytizing cult that would exclude any other outlook upon life. The process itself orgues a mind dalled and stupefied by the contemplation of obscene until, as it has been well vd, the votary is incapable trae beauty, of under-for example, the look and stnile of La Ginconda or the hyvmonious and living majesty of the Victory of Samothrace. If th's he the effect on a mind attuned to the wsthetic, its intacnee on the more numerous ales whose instincts are rer the surface can readily be imo.ined. The marked popularity itcrature of this cult can ly he innered by those who feel callvl. upon to study the problem of race suicide. There is room, indeed, for the spread of moral education; and while in no other sphere can its inculcation be so effective as in the home, if the opportunities there are neglected, an attempt must be made in the school to recover the lost ground.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account