The Archive · 1908

Prisons in the City

In the middloof July Mr. Pao, the Mixed Court Magistrate, made representations to the Senior Consal in regard to the treatment, during the hot weather, of convicts why are serving sentences in the Municipal Gaol. the interests of "humanity "mercy," and on the ground that hard labour in the hot air and the blazing sun was too rigorous, and certainly in disagreement with Chinese law, Mr. Pao. asked for a remission of the convicts' labour daring the smurrier, It would seem that in this particular instance Chinese Iam, hnwanity and mercy, are' more jealous of the treatment of criminal than of the industrious cool who does not come within reach of the arm of justice; for while ricsha, wheelbarrow, hand-cart and other coolies must work just the same, whether the wea ther be cold or hot, earning their livd hood in very truth by the sweat of their brow, it appears to come as a shock to Chinese susceptibilities to see a gang of Chinese convicts, chained, it ix trae, bnt with their heads well protected from the sun, dragging a roller at the rate of a mile an hour.

Apparently this point of view has not entered into the mind of the Bagistrate, any more than the equally obvious comparison of the treatment of Municipal prisoners with that meted out to criminals in the City. The means of making such a comparison must be ready to hand with a Chinese official, whereas there are many obstacles in the way of a foreigner, not: only because it is impossible to obtain admission to all Chinese prisons, but also because from the Chinese standpoint sanitary precautions, regular In-on, strict discipline, and good food are only regarded as advantages by pen-niles prisoners whose means would not allow them, if imprisoned in the City, to supplement their scanty rations with food from outside. It must be obvious, however, that the convict is the very last person who should be consulted in regard to his treatment indeed, if he prefers to occupy vermin-ons quarters in order that he.may idle away his time, it is not because he is ture hamaraly treated, bat because be considers that the advantages of imprisonment on the Chinese system outweigh the disadvantages of over-crowding, leg irone, and other inconveniences connected with " native prison.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account