The Archive · 1924

Risks of Rioting

July 16.

IN the recent libel action which Michael O'Dwyer, formerly Lieutenant Governor of the Punjab, brought against Sir Sankaran Nair, formerly a high Indian official, and which re-sulled in the plaintiff being awarded £500 damages and the costs of the action, the investiga tion ranged over a wide field. One important question consider Chimneys.

of our, manufacturing °4_ i the Judge's charge to the to pour i tifleation, jury was the justification, or chemicals into the air which, if treated scientifically, would be a source of wealth to us instead of cause of disease, a blight on the countryside and a ceaseless reproach for our indifference and lack of enterprise, It is, or, perhaps, we should say, was, the custom of certain writers to pour contempt on the Chinese for their apathy in neglecting to' develop—_ the resources of their country lest, in so doing, they should injure the mysterious ""feng-shui" which is essential to the' well-being of the nation, These writers pointed out that this purblind con-servetism condemned the masses te poverty and ignorance with all their attendant evils. But whatever reproach may, in this connexion, be levelled at the Chinese can, with ten-fold effect, be applied to ourselves. The mineral wealth which they allow to lie hidden in the bowels of the earth is, at least, harmless there. But we, by an ingenious use of giant chimneys, diffuse our potential wealth, in the form of gaseous chemicals, far and wide over the land and, in so doing, make the healthful breezes seatter grime and dirt, sickness and death wherever they blow. We therefore hail the coming of a man who is going to do what lies within the power of an individual to cleanse one city from the death-dealing smoke evil. Sir H. Dennis Readett-Bayley is a wealthy colliery owner. If he can prove that there is money in the process of turning smoke into petrol, he will doubtless have imitators, though Ruskin wore his heart out in vain efforts to persuade the people of England to save the children from death and the fair fields of their land from pollution. Even his match-Tess prose was powerless to evoke more than a sneer from those whose duty it was to care for these things. It is like a fairy tale; gold for grime. So many hundreds of pounds otherwise, of the stern measures used by the military authority when called upon by the civil authorities to suppress a riotous meeting in northern India which, not suppressed, might have had the most disastrous and widespread consequences. The suppression of rioting, especially when the rioters are ignorant and follow blindly the guidance of unscrupulous leaders, is a most dificult and distressing duty to all in authority. Some yairs ago, when Lord Haldane was Secretary of State for War, the writer heard a very interest ing debate on this subject in the House of Commons. All the speakers, whether civil or military, who had taken part in the suppression of riots, expressed their extreme dislike of being obliged to act in such emergent cle, Nevertheless, public order had to be maintained.

The duty is still more dificult countries, such as Ind where the rioters belong to one race and those in authority another. It is all very well for persons living in countries where law and order are well established to criticize official proceedings taken in a nioment of extreme danger with no' other motive than to save the lives of thousands of men, wamel, and children; were they actually present at the scene and aware of all the circumstances intensity of the pa of Orientals, they would think differently, In China, fortunately, the people on the whole are Jess easily stirred to rioting than in other parts of the Orient. Still, even here riots have often occurred, lives have been lost, property' destroyed, and the present discontent and lawlessness are so widespread that no one can tell what may happen at any time and place.. It is well, therefore, that political agitators and other persons, whether Chinese of foreign, inclined to foment public disturbances, should at least know the risks they run where, English law prevails. In the tial to

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account