The Archive · 1924

THE JAPANESE AND MORMONISM

Aug. 19.

Ir has been recently announced that, after twenty-two years of missionary effort in Japan, the "Latter-Day Saints" have withdrawn their workers from that country. The statement is made, apparently with official sanction, that there is not at present a single Japanese man or woman who lias been converted to Mormonism. Work of this kind is very discouraging. What is the cause of the failure? The recent earthquake disaster and international difitulties, over immigration laws may have had some -efféct in hastening the' decision to end the mission, but the main cause or causes must be deeper. The subject is of gene al interest, as whatever throws light on the Japanese response to Western religious appeals illummates also, to some extent at least, their general reaction to whatever is rfovel to them in our Western civilization.

In the popular imagination, Mormonism consists mainly in the claim and practice of its founders that, as part of their' religion, they had the right to follow the example of King Solomon and other Old Testament! worthies and marry a plurality of wives, a reversion to a primitive custom which aroused intense hostility in the United States.

No doubt much emphasis was. formerly laid on this custom by. the Mormon Church, but for some years past polygamous marriages have been officially prohibited by' it in accordance with the demand of the United States Government.

At any rate, it is doubtful when ther the preaching of polygamy, in and by itself, would be an in-' superable obstacle to missionary. success in the Orient. The failure must be due to other difficulties. Probably the decided objection of the Japanese to acknowledging the supremacy of a foreign organization in a for country has much to do with it, Loyalty to their own government, is part of their religious creed. In 1889, the Mormons were refused admittance to the full rights of American citizenship on the ground that "the Mormon Church is a treasonable organiza tion hostile to the Government of the United States, and that the oaths administered to its members on the occasion of their passing through the initiation ceremonies of endowment' bind them to render implicit obedience, not only in things spiritual, but also in things temporal and political, to the priests and officers of their church." The Jong and unfortunate history of the opposition of the Mormon Church to the United States Government and its claim to the unquestioning and full obedience of all its members throughout the world would be quite sufficient to render its propaganda of little or no avail with the intensely patriotic Japanese. Moreover, it is part of its teaching that the millennium is coming and that! Zion, the Mormon Church, then will be established in all its glory in America. The Japanese may ask, why should America, of all countries in the world, have this particular glory? Briefly, if the Japanese desired to become Mormons, it would be incumbent upon them to give their principal allegiance to the Mormon Church in the United States, their own country, government, and national and family ties taking a very subordinate place. This is a very serious handicap to any mission ary organization desiring to convert people so intensely patriotic as the Japanese. Apart from polygamy, there is much that is good in Mormon teaching, but it is not surprising—that! Mormonism has utterly failed to gain a foothold in Japan. Nor isit likely that it will succeed in China.

To the dispassionate observer, the present struggle of religions in the East must be very informing and interesting. The native religions will soon discard the customs, practices and beliefs which make them peculiarly vulnerable to adverse criticism, and will thereby become more formidable, more national, and their followers less likely to change. Missionary religions from other parts of the world, Christianity included, to win success must rest more' and more exclusively on purely spiritual principles, and minimise whatever in their teaching is foreign or peculiarly temporary and local. The Chinese Christians are not wholly unreasonable when they, object to being burdened, with the denominational differences of the West, although it would be well for them if they understood the religious principles, the points of contention, which tie at the root of these' differences, There no short cut to Sound religious thinking and yet the teaching must be in a form assimilable by the people to whom it is presented. What doctrines and core: monies will be part of Christianity in El after foreign Christian teaching has passed through the alembic of the Chinese mind and the doctrinal and other divergencies of the numerous foreign denominations have been weighed, it is hard to predict Perhaps it might lessen the co1 fusion and help the missionary cause generally if denominations Which are not succeeding would either retire, as the Mormons have done in Japan, or unite with stronger denominations from which they differ only on minor points,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account