The Archive · 1920

THE MOTOR-CAR CASE

Damages of $900 Against Mr. Bland As the result of the judgement en im.M. Supreme Court on saturday, by his Honour Judge Skinner Turner, Mr. H. Bland, of the Municipal Health Department, was mulcted in the sum of $960 damages together with costs, in the action brought against him by Ma) Ying-tsin to recover $1,318 damages ar from the alleged negligent!

of the defendant, whereby inti was knocked down, sustain-cuts to his face and a broken Reader Harris appeared plaintiff and Mx, F, Lipson for th His Lordshij qient, seid Tu this case the plaintiff asks for ai nages fur personal injuries caused the negligent driving of his motor-car by the defendant. The defendant denies the negligence and pleads that the accident was really, caused by the plaintiffs own negligence. I am very glad to say that the suggestion of callousness made against the defendant for his behaviour after the accident has' been entirely disproved and has been very properly withdrawn by' the plaintiff. I think I can understand how it came to be made, but as the plaintiff knew that the defendant came to the hospital to see him after the accident it seems to me that the suggestion ought to have been more carefully—considered. The short facts are that the plaintiff was walking home with a friend from his office on February 17 last about 5.15 p.m.; it was raining and he had an umbrella up, sharing it with his friend. They were proceeding down the Szechuen Road to-yards the creek, walking on the left-hand side of the roadway (there is no foot-path on that side): the plaintiff being on the outside. Before reaching the Soochow Road crossing the plaintiff was knocked down by the defendant's motor-car and sustained injuries, the principal one being a fracture of both bones: of his left leg near the ankle, he was away from his work for two months. The car was proceeding in the same direction as the plaintiff was overtaking him: it was: driven by the defendant himself, who has had considerable experi ence in driving, though at that time, not very much in Shanghai. After the accident, the plaintiff was taken out from' under the car: it was moved on by the polic the Plaintiff was put into the ricsha of a Mr. Stanley who came upon the scene and offered its use (conduct for which I have already thanked} Rond Hospital. The defendant re-him) and taken to the Shantung) turned to the scene immediately after he had moved his car away and took all proper steps to aid the plaintiff. I am quite satisfied as to

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account