The Archive · 1924

His Defects

Yet the missionary has all the! lGefects of his qualities, admirable jas they are. If he adheres so. loyally and gives himself so freely. to his ideals, it is natural that he should be unquestioning about-them Jand should take a simple view of fall life. And those to whom life is clear-cut, black and white, good/and bad, are not always the-most comprehending, the most discerning and the most delicate in human situations. Mission work, therefore, is mot so easily dealt with as mis-jon ary personality. The part of it that may be called for short "humanitarian" is all the word connotes. 'The campaign against foot-binding, opium and similar evils lowes mich to missionary influence. To missionaries must be given leredit for fighting foreign exploitaion of the Chinese, though usually in vain, 'Through' the beneficent Iabours of medical missions islands lof health have been created in an expanse of filth, disease and waste jof life. The religious, social and educational work, however, all that raises questions of comparative creeds and comparative civilizations, reflects to a greater or less degree the limitations of missionaries, I have already touched on the background of the average missionary. It must be understood the is to be understood; for it explains him. He left his native land young. The chances are that of the stuff of life in his native Innd he knew but little. In the small communities from which he and most of his fellows came, conformity was the rule. The naked and the raw Idid not exist or were concealed. Even extreme poverty, with all that flows from it, was seldom found; intensity of passion, almost Inever. There was the great mean there was a grand simplicity of Jeonduet, preached and enforced by minister and his vestry Nor had the missionary any famil write with the critical literature of his own country. Not joven indirectly had his assurance been disturbed, With such a background young men and women came to China—or Japan or Korea or India—bearing light unto the darkness. In their new countries, however, they did see life in the raw. As aliens, they. did not immediately find soft shelter And, as foreigners, they came with Jopen eyes and critical faculties and prejudice against the unfamiliar, Seeing life naked, without the eortective of knowing life at home in the same way, they of course idealized their own countries and Jadopted an air of superiority. You have there the explanation of three striking characteristics of Protestant evangelical workers in foreign Lauds: self-complacency in the face of different social customs and insstitutions; assumption of their own lexelusive theological rightness rigidity about matters of conduct.

Take merely the word "heather The use of that word and the recent .{deetine in use are both signifi-leant. The modern young men of the missions have learned that ther are religions and civilizations other than their own not unworthy of consideration. At least some of them concede a certain dignity to Chinese civilization, for instance, if not to Chinese religious tenets. They have learned, too, that life is not all sublime in America either. Even so, such men are a minority. In Korea, T have asked missionaries thow many schools there were in a certain town. "Five," was the answer; "two of ours and three heathen.'

T have asked whether

accomplished Confucian man of culture was interested in their no, he's a heathen!" reply.

The Patronizing Note.

The same attitude is reflected in print. It hapifens that much the literature in English on the Far East has been written by mis. sionaries. Through nearly all of it runs the superior,—patroni leven contemptuous note. The warpig of European and American opinion on Far Eastern countries jim large measure due to this literature, the result of the fact that those through whose eyes the West Fhas seen the East have not had the equipment to understand or to judge what they saw. The missionaries have raised their voice against poli tical aggression from the West, but by their disparagement eastern cultures they have also helped to bring on that aggression.

One of the best books on the Chinese people, for instance, is Dr. Arthur Lil. Smith's "Chinese Characteristies." It is an excellent work, [witty and, on the whole, autho tive. The criticism is, however tearingly destructive and the conclusion is that, admirable as the Chinese people may be, they need moral regeneration, which can come But a Chinese of equal ability and jas much "knowledge of America might have made a similar examination of American society and American character and, taking into Jaccount our industrial and economic system, our political corruption, our slums and commercialized vice, our diplomatic iniquities and our wars {for raw materials and markets, might have concluded that we, too, despite many good qualities, needed moral regeneration, which could come about only through conversion Buddhism. Or, he might have said, if he wanted to be ironical, through conversion to Christianity, Had Dr. Smith, when he wrote his book in 1890, known as much about: the life of a Pennsylvania mill town as he did about his Shantung and Chili villages, his tone would have been different." In fact, in what he [has written in recent years, his tone actually has been different, But Dr, Smith is a scholar and man of parts. The reactions and reports lof the majority of missionaries, who fave neither, can be imagined.

Once, while staying on Taishan, ithe sacred mountain in Shantung, I decided to make a trip to Chufu, ithe home of Confuctus, not far distant. There the body of Confucius lies buried in a graveyard that is, I think, endowed with the highest dignity and the most austere beauty of any in the world; and there his descendants, the clan of K'ung, still ive. From Duke Kung, head of the clan in direct descent from Jeldest son to eldest son and the only hereditary duke in the country by that fact, ty the water-carriers dri the streets of the dusty village, practically all of the inhabitants are of the Kung family. And all, whether duke or water-carrier, are, because of their lineage, equally en: titled after death to lie within ved walls that enclose the burial-place of Confucius himself. There also the government, whether public or monarchy, sends its representatives every year to make the nation's obeisance at the birth= day ceremonials of the sage, It is in every sense a holy city:

Starting from Taishan, T was necompanied by a missionary, who told me he would stop at Chuft, too, beeatise he had a church there. expressed surprise at that and asked him to explain, He did. A" few years before, his mission had attempted to lease property in Chutu for a station, It should be understood that, "directly o¥. indirectly, through a treaty imposed on China by the West Jatter one of its wars of aggression, Christian missionaries wave the right to live and work nywhere in China, The irony that inheres in the propagation of the Gospel of the Prince of Peace by the sanction of guns on war-ships pars over without comment, just. jas the missionaries do, By virtue of this Jegal right the mission went. to the district authorities, who are elders of the K'ung family, for permission to lease property.' The authorities demurred strongly. They pointed out what that city symbolize fed to the Chinese people in religious sunetity, and they asked that there only, in the city where highest honour is paid to the founder of a great philosophy, older than Chrisianity, the mission voluntarily. waive its right to proselyte. All ithe rest of China was open to it without hindrance. That one spot it might leave, unmolested, to its memories. The—mission saw the point mor accepted the rebuff. It did not press the matter further with the authorities. Instead, its representatives went to 'a sympathetic family in the country, \duced the head of it to buy a piece lof property and then leased it from him. They built a church. They thad won. I have never discussed this incident with a missionary who thas not gloated over it or who showed any sensitiveness to the lauestion of taste and feeling involved. I do not say there are no [such missionaries. I only say shave never met one,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account