The Archive · 1920

Labour and Liquor

The Carlisle Experiment

The members of the Trade Union and Labour movements who recently visited Carlisle to examine the Liquor Control Board's experiment in that area have now issued their report. They conclude that the Board is to be congratulated on most remarkable achievement," which has more than justified itself.

"Tt has proved," the signatories agree, "that State enterprise is not necessarily inefficient, that the elimination of private profit and competition may mean the elimination of waste, that public ownership isan. effective means of reducing excessive drinking, and that a State-owned enterprise may be conducted with imagination and public spirit.

"Tt is a fact that a very large section of the people of this country consume alcoholic beverages, and that this must be taken into account in the future policy of the nation. We believe that the real line of advance is in the direction pointed out by the Carlisle scheme.

"We hope that the influence of the organized Labour movement will be brought to bear upon the Government to ensure that an end 1s put to the system of private ownership, which thrives at the expense of the workers, and that there is substituted for it a system based upon public ownership and full public control."

Tae Inpucemest 10 Drink:

the report points out that the members of the party did not go to Carlisle holding a common point of view on temperance policy and the drink question. Some were total abstainers and some were not. The common bond between them was that they were members of the same movement, and had much the same outlook on economic questions, One thing they were clear about was that the number of public houses in the country was excessive, and that the Control Board were wise in taking steps to reduce the number of [icerices im Carlisle, steps which, in the opinion of the party, had bad beneficial results.

Although the worst of the public-houses had been swept away (the report proceeds), we realized vividly something of the meanness and inadequacy of the older type of licensed house. We feel that the workers are entitled to surroundings of a finer type, and in the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account