The Archive · 1927

Indians Charged with Conspiracy

In HM, Police Court on Mor the Magistrate, Br, committed three Tndians for land. discharged the other seve! the ease in which. the; were. all:

Mr, Faison:—You constitute yourself asa guardian for these Japanese girls, do you not?—Yes, they are under contract and I have to carry out the provisions, An employee of Mr. Scott, and a former house servant in their home, said that he had-never noticed any trouble in the family.

Addressing the Court, Mr_ Faison that conditions, had een phd peler to 1925 that his client had! Bape.to Mr, B, S: Cuohinghari, [Consul-General, for protection, and later both she and respondent went Mr, Franklin's law office, where! after lengthy conferences it was! agreed and a document signed, whereby they were to resume their At this time re-

Tu conclusion, counsel suggested that the children would not have a fair chance in life, if they were required to live under such conditions had existed.

Mr. F. J, Schuhl then said that most of the evidence had not been corroborated, excepting the a fon New Year's Eve. Counsel ized that respondent's business was not of the best, but he tried to keep it as respectable as possible. It iwas under emergency conditions that he brought the dancing girls to his home to sleep and eat. Counsel suggested that everything posible should be done to effect a reconciliation between the parties for the children's sake and intimated \that the Court should permit them to "try-it" again, this juncture plaintiff's face] was covered with frowns and Mr. Faigon told the Court that she had! teied to live with respondent in 1925) and that she was absolutely unwilling to try life together again.

The Judgment Judge Purdy:—The situation as [presented in this case is not to be unexpected from the life of the parties concerned, but the parties are not entitled to so much considera-_ {tion as the children, who are the un-_ fortunate victims to suffer the most.

[But that is always the case and this Court has to try and take care of that situation, Further, his Honour commented! on the unfortunate position of having a mother-in-law so near. It appeared to him that the husband's very move aroused the ire and inger of the mother-in-law, and rebably what she said and did had similar effect_on_ respondent. There were greater difficulties to be met, however, he went on to say.

If they could be brought together the Court would welcome the reconciliation. They had had trouble two years ago and drew up an agreement, pat such a document can have no solemnity, when-they have not observed the solemnity of the marriage covenant," concluded his Honour, Commenting on respondent's actions Judge Purdy said that he could not understand how one could fenter into such a business and then virtually drive his wife and children {into the midst of it: they could have. been kept in another portion of the ety. "Such a house is nothing but 'a place of assignation, and, he Drought the girls into his home," he went on to say. "I have no patience with such a man."

About the trouble between wife and husband and the latter's alleged cruelty, he said. "Why, you can't run a wife like a ship, with belaying pin!"

Again about the cabaret, "Women who work in such a place are not respectable and cannot be called such—the women are unfortunate, it is true—and at the same time to keep a wife and children around it, T cannot comprehen¢ it. It's a wonder to me that Mrs, Scott has not become contaminated by the influence, but she has stayed respect-

In conclusion Judge Purdy said, If he wants to keep his wife and children, he should throw the dance hall dancing girls into the [Huangpu River, Judge Purdy granted an inter-' locutory decree to plaintiff, custody lof the children and their maintenance which he fixed at Mex. $125 per month, refusing Mr. Faison' request for counsel's fees from re-]spondent. His Honour informed Mr. Scott that he could see his children once or even twice a week at a convenient place, but not in the cabaret.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account