The Archive · 1927

Despatch of the Defence Force

Wise as was the Memorandum of December last, to which I have already referred, ill wiser was the despatch of ti Defence Force to Shanghai is difficult to exaggerate the gratitude and relief which this action inspired, but it is not only because it averted a disaster that the step deserves praise. Can anyone doubt that the set-back to the extremists, evident during the last few days, and the provement, in the fortunes of the moderates, does not directly find its stimulus' from their presence? or justice, or fairness in the Chinese laun for the return of the foreign Settlements to their control. They were not extorted from the Chinese Government under unfair Treati it was the Government of China which, many years ago, flatly refused to allow the "outer barbarians" to live and trade in the Middle Kingdom, but consented to their being allowed to live and trade in small areas set apart near to the cities, ud these areas had developed into large and flourishing Settlement:

Mr. A. H. Harris asked the Ckairman if he could inform the meeting, with regard to the leter sent by the Association to the Foreign Office, what intercourse took place between the authorities at Hankow and the representatives of the foreign community, and whether the discussions were taken in public o in came The Chairman replied that he understood the discussions were conducted in camera.

Mr. Harris said that, in that case, he thought the letter of the Associa: tion to the Foreign Office might have been more strongly worded, In his opinion, the agreement was an altruistic agreement, and those who would suffer from it would be their countrymen on the spot, those who Rived there on the strength of treaties to which their own Government had put their hand, The Chairman said that, whilst the negotiations were going' on, the Association was not informed' exactly what the character of thoss negotiations were; the Association had an opportunity of expressing its own views—which were very similar to those put forward by Mr. Harris—to the Foreign Omice, which was thoroughly aware that the sources of information which the Association had on this side were always at its disposal.

Mr. Harris asked why, then, were [the views of the China Association On the question of the abolition of extraterritoriality in the present] lid the China Committee absolutely ignored? In his opinion the Settle-state of China's development, I do not think I can do better than you to the able address by Mr. Silas Strawn, bound up with our ssnaal report. 'Mr. Strawn was the 'American representative on the International Commission, and. his condemnation of the disorganization and corruption which exists in China should be pondered over by those] who cherish the illusion' that there is egal system effective in China, to which either they themselves, or their fellow-countrymen, could should be made subject.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account