The Archive · 1920

Dispute Between Counsel

COLLISION ON THE YANGTZE

and Witness 'The case in which the China Merchants' Steam Navigation Ca. is seeking to recover damages from the Asiatic Petroleum Ca. (North China), Ld., arising out of a collision between the str. Kiangtung, belonging to the plaintiffs, and the tug Yang Peh and two lighters, belonging to the defendant company, was concluded last Friday in H. M. Supreme Court, before his Honour Judge Skinner Turner.

Mr. R. N. Macleod, with whom was Mr. Brockman, appeared for the plaintiffs, and Mr. £. L. Har-tapp for the defence.

The last witness called for the defendants was Kuang Ching-ping, a member of the crew of the Yang Peh. He was standing in the wheelhouse immediately before and at the time of the collision. The Yang Peh gave a blast of her whistle on seeing the lights of the Kiangtung, and another blast shortly afterwards, a third blast being sounded just before the collision took place. Witness did not hear the Kiangtung's whistle at all.

Kuanetena Wirsesses Recattep.

Mr. Macleod asked leave to call evidence in rebuttal, particularly with regard to the place where defendants alleged the collision took place, and his Lordship agreed to the recalling of Mr. Langvad and Mr. Bayes Davey:

Mr. Langvad gave evidence with regard to the left bank of the river near the point where the collision occurred, and was cross-examined by Mr. Hartopp as to how he knew so much about the river at that point, having according to his own statement only made one previous trip.

"Haven't you been coached this morning about this?

"No," witness replied. "No one has spoken to we about it.'"

"I can't check you," counsel retorted, "but it looks very much like it."

Captain Bayes Davey, recalled, spoke of his survey of the Kiang-tung as to the damage done in collision. He should say that. the Kianctung had very little headway at the time she was struck. She received a very sharp, heavy blow, rebounding, and the vessel by which she was struck must have had very good way on.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account