Sept. 4.
We have received a very interesting letter from Canton dealing with comments passed in this and other papers on the settlement of the Shameen strike, The writer throws a good deal of light on points hitherto, for some reason, curiously obscure. He shows that the statement of our leading article of August 20 that the foreigners only won on the question of the reinstatement of the police was not correct; furthermore, there was a good deal of feeling, well justified, in Shameen at the assumption (not, taken in these columns but in some other quarters) that the strike was weakly handled by the foreign authorities. On this latter subject he writes:— we had adopted the gunboat policy, we were certainly entitled to refuse to meet the strikers' dolezates until they had definitely come into the open with their complaint. The only sign of wenk= ness (2) was in obtaining the intervention of the Canton Government, cent. of people behaving against the interests if we had not. channel possible for a settlement instead of fighting the to a finish by refusing to th anybody else except. the and their delegates.
In respect of the police our correspondent thinks that they are just as much entitled to strike as anybody else if unjustly treated; but, he says, "What they should not do is to allow themselves to be intimidated in order to assist another body of strikers with whom they had nothing in common, their duty lying entirely in the opposite direction." This is perfectly sound reasoning and in view of the strength of the Bolshevik agitation in Canton the Shameen authorities are much to be congratulated on having upheld their point that }the police were in no eireumstances to be reinstated. The matter of the passports never presented any difficulty: the foreigners were perfectly willing ite carry these themselves order that there might be no idea of discrimination against the Chinese. As regards Chinese being free to uée the Shameen as a thoroughfare, against which there is a very ancient regulation, our correspondent points out that the observance of this rule had long been getting slack and that the determination of the foreigners to reinforce it dated from long before the bomb outrage, and was the cause of much agitation in the Chinese press. On this point the strike agreement entirely gives the victory to the foreigners. In the matter of servants' pay during the weeks of strife, we understand that this was to be left to the clemency of individual masters and mistresses. There has been no difficulty. in the matter at all. Whether the money was paid or not, the servants were so glad to get back to work, and set to at once with such energy, scrubbing, brushing, and cleaning, that for a day or two, as our correspondent humorously says, many' residents found their' houses most uninhabitable and came very near to wishing that the strike had never been settled!
From the above statement it is clear that the Shameen com-, munity. won' a conspicuous success. The agreement was wrapped up in flowery. language for the very natural reason that no one wished to exacerbate feeling unduly, It is important, however, that the rights of the issue should be clearly understood, because it was never really a fight between the Shameen servants. and their masters, but between the Bolshevist element in the Kuomintang and the foreign community, As such the latter recognized it from the outset, and' with the example of the regrettable, climb-down at Hongkong in the big shipping strike, where exactly the same issue w really involved, they were resolved that they would not give in, For five full weeks they "stuck it out," in the height of a Canton summer, doing all their own work, not only in discomfort but it may even have been in danger. In the long run they were victorious, the agitators were completely discomfited and the residents of Shameen won a success on which they are not only to be congratulated but on which, in the circumstances prevailing in South China to-day, they are entitled to the thanks of their fellows in other parts of China,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.