The Archive · 1927

AN AMERICAN'S STORY OF THE NANKING OUTRAGE

Misleading Statements in the "Christian Century" Controverted by a Full Account of the Facts: The Danger of Those on Socony Hill We have received a copy of a letter written by the Rev. J. Magee of Hsiakuan to the editor of the "Christian Century" which gives a clear account of the position of Nanking during the bombardment of March 24. Mr. Magee says in his lette The Editor of the "Christian Century"

Sin—I have recently read your issue of April 7, and at this late date would like to try to clear up some of the questions you ask regarding the bombardment—at Naking on March 24. I live just outside the city wall in plain view of the Standard Oil Ca, residences, and was in communication by telephone and by an improvised plan of signals with the party who were there. Because of this I like to try and give a what actually happened.

There was no general bombardment of the city as seems to be the popular impression (even among missionaries in other parts of China). During the period of shelling, which may have lasted, as you reported, an hour and a half between the' first arid last shots, there way no constant, uninterruptshelling.

There were several Ni bursts of intense fire, expecially at the beginning, but there were also periods of silence, From people who said they counted the shots I heard that from 60 to 70 shells were fired. I should say that there was an interval of at least 20 between the firing shell and that which preceded but the navy records would provide the only accurate report of that as well as of the number of shells fired, The Bombardment The bombardment did not "descend on a thickly settled section of Nanking" as you reported, Dut was confined almost entirely to barrage around the Standard Oil Ca, manager's residence where 48 foreigners almost all Americans, were fighting for their lives. There no Chinese houses near these houses, as this is a section of, Nanking, formerly vacant, where the foreign firms have built residences for their foreign staffs, There are a few scattered farm-houses over beyond the hill and a village outside the wall to the left of the me of fire. I did hear later that} machine guns had been turned on, the bund to clear it of soldiers when a landing party of about 80, American sailors was sent ashore to try and rescue the party in this Standard Oil house. This apparent. ly did not do much damage as I came along there about 30 minutes! to an hour later (not knowing of; this machine-gun fire) and found one wounded coolie a little back from the bund. The other coolies who were carrying him told me he had been hit by a ricocheted bullet. Whether others were wounded I do standing their hut who seem-not know. I saw other coolies

ed to know me, and when T stopped to ask them the whereabouts of any sailors on the bund they said nothing of this machine-gun fire which I did not know about till T got on the ship, who Standard Oil Ca. residence was agreed upon some days before by the British and American naval officers as a good place for foreigners to congregate in case of danger as it stands on a bill overlooking the wall in plain view of the river, and yrould be an easy place from which to climb down over the wall by the rope ladder which had been placed in the house beforehand to meet such an emergency.

The first few people to gather' there after the unexpected attacks by the Nationalist troops thought it was time to get out, and two or. three had actually descended over' the wall by the rope. Just then some soldiers came along. telling them it was all right and that they could go back to the house. Those who hi already descended went on to the river while the others returned to the house leaving the rope Inder which was later removed, presumably by these soldiers, Arrival of Mr. Davis After this Consul Davis arrived with a party of 23 Americans, in-eluding his wife and two children and a guard of 11 sailors with an officer, the whole party having had a run of about two miles across country from the Consulate in which they were a great part of way under fire, Mr. Davis had given orders to the sailors not to return the fire and this was adhered to except when one sailor was slightly Wounded and knocked down by a bullet, This sailor stopped Tong enough to shoot two of his assailants. Upon arrival the Consul telephoned to the Vice-Consul, Mr. Paxton, who had taken refuge in my house the night before when he was caught outside the city wall during the looting of this section of the city by the Northern troops in their rapid retreat, Mr, Davis told Us of the terrible happenings inside the city and asked us to try and get into communication with some analist authority who could deliver them from their predicament and stop the outrages in other parts of the city. I im. mediately sent word to the local Kuomintang (at the Hsiakuan branch outside the city wall), the head man of which is a. communieant of our parish, and Inter Went twice myself to headquarters. They told me there that they were not yet in touch with any responsible military officer. We finally succeeded in getting them to send about five unarmed men to attempt to rescue the party at the Standard Oi hill, The Threat to Kill In the meantime the Consul daring a period of several hours, at imminent risk to his own life, had been attempting to deal with cessive groups of, soldiers who kept coming for loot. He was repeatedly told that he would be killed, and rifles were loaded and pointed at him. On one occasion the soldiers told the servants that if he came out again they would surely kill him, In spite of this he did go out) taking more money gathered from the people hidden inside. He also knew at that time that two people had been killed at the British Consulate nearby and others wounded '4s well as of the death of Dr. Williams and others further off, Finally, when the soldiers broke into the house and pushed Mr. Davis to the foot of the stairs with bayonet pressing into his chest, he called out, "I cannot hold them any longer," or something. similar. Here Ensign Phelps with several sailors rushed down the stairs at sight of whom the soldiers fied out of the house. I was told afterwards by those.inside the house that the Chinese soldiers were already firing outside when Ensign Phelps cried out, "Shall we open fire?," and that Mr. Davis had said, "Shoot over their heads."

Later, to keep back the increasing number'of soldiers who were firing at them, the order was given to shoot to kill. At one time the Consul gave the order to signal for help to the gunboats and then almost immediately countermanded the order. He himself told me afterwards that he thought at the time that this might mean the death of all of them but he feared for the 120 people up at the missionary centre if the gunboats fired. The whole party were lying on: the upper floors, and such as had guns. were defending themselves, shooting. through the windows. Several of. them told me that they never expected to come out alive and that they had said good-bye to one another all around. Death seemd but a matter of minutes as I believe the soldiers were already inside tha house on the ground-floor. Finally, Ensgin Phelps said to the Conaul:—"We cannot hold out any longer," and then at last Mr. Davis told him ito send the S, 0. 8, to the warships. The gunboats immediately sent "a barrage of shrapnel and shells around. the house, and the soldiers soon fled. As they fled in one direction the foreigners fled down the hill to the wall in the other, and clambered down over the wall on improvised roves, made of curtains, sheets, ete, The Number Killed As I was taken on the gunboat in the same launch with some of this party and was thrown with others of them afterwards I had plenty of opportunity for questioning them. I asked a.numtber of them as to the numbers of the soldiers attacking them and all said it was difficult to say as they were hiding behind other buildings, mudbanks, ete. One business man told me he thought there were possibly 400. I was also told that it was impossible to say how many soldiers had been killed by the rifle fire from the house and by the bombardment. One man said he thought the number might have been about 100. Some of the shells were seen to a light among the soldiers, The next day I was told by dictionaries who had been further up in the city that about three shells fell near the Drum Tower, three of four miles away, but when ther they were fired there by design or not I do not know. Possibly they were fired at the Military Governor's yamen and fell short. Two or three civilians are reported to have been killed by these shells but I cannot vouch for the accuracy of this. General Chiang Kal after his visit to Nanking a few days. later, reported that in alt six had been killed and 15 wounded (I think he meant civilians), but in time -when there was '9 much general shooting and. rioting would be a difficult thing to say how many were killed or wounded by fire from the warships. One coolie that I heard of who was trying to carry a message rom foreigners is hiding in the Yangtze Villa Hotel at Hsiakuan was shot dead by a soldier before he had gone far. This hotel is not far from the bund with open space in between. One lady in the Presbyterian Mission told me that two people were killed in ber house in the mad scramble for loot. Th are but a fow instances of the reckese killing of Chinese civilians on that awful day and it seems likely there must have been more in view of the haphazard shooting that was taking place all over the city.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account