The Archive · 1924

Analogy from Europe

Students of government will roemiber that at about the same time that the Anglo-Saxon Council England was becoming a Parliament, the Frankish Council develop into the Estates Gener Parliament as early as John began its career of controlling the Ki it gained control over the taxes of the country and therefore over the whole financial system, In France, however, the king was authorized collect a specific tax for the raising of a standing army and for the suppression of troops, He therefore controlled certain revenues without the consent of the Estate General and he had a standing army to assist him. In both, he was in= dependent of Parliament; while the English kings from John'to Edward T became more and more dependent upon the will of Parliament. France, the Estates: General became unimportant; in England, Par ment became the powe Is it not remarkable that two people as akin as the Anglo-Normans of England and the Frankish-Normans of France should develop so differently? Yet, many factors entered into that difference: /geographical, religious, traditional, the outcome of wars, the tenure of and, ete, Bringing the situation back to ina, one 's faced with exactly the same ' problem, namely, that though many nations appear to be alike, each is different, and what may be tru in one, may be alto in another, To reason form of government altogether on the basis of analogies with other countries and without regard for the peculiarities of thir particular country is what has led to all the troubles in the land, from the beginning of the era of reform until to-day.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account