Wo are reluctant to appear unsympathetic but it is difficult to see that any useful purpose is to ye served by letters suggesting that the building of a United Services' Club would be an appropriate Shanghai War Memorial: for two reasons—(1) the Cenotaph has definitely been chosen and (2) the Club scheme is quite impracticable. Our correspondents overlook that the memorial is a Shanghai War Memorial, not a British memorial. It, is designed to com-morate the part taken in the war y the Allies of Shanghai; and it ems to follow that a club for the uso and benefit of any section, or sections, of the community is out of the question. Even had the establishment of such an_institution been mooted in the first instance, before the Cenotaph was chosen, the scheme must have been abandoned as being impossible, for a memorial club should not be exclusive to any one nationality, and the difficulties in the way of its being open to all are "too numerous to mention." It will perhaps be generally conceded that the Com-ruttee has chosen wisely in selecting a memorial which is purely impersonal and therefore repre sentative of all—its, essential principle. Another point to he remem-hered is this: funds already subseribed have been subscribed for a definite object, and_ contributors would be perfectly justified were they to object to their diversion into other channels.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.